Skip to content

PROGRESS.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
263 lines (228 loc) · 72.7 KB

PROGRESS.md

File metadata and controls

263 lines (228 loc) · 72.7 KB

VerifiedJS — Progress Tracker

Pipeline Status

Pass Syntax Semantics Interp Print Pass Impl Proof
Source (AST) ✅ full ES2020 N/A N/A baseline N/A N/A
Lexer/Parser ✅ N/A N/A N/A ✅ recursive descent (96.30% flagship coverage, 1976/2052 on 2026-03-08) N/A
Core ✅ ✅ step? ✅ small-step driver ✅ full pretty-printer Elaborate: ✅ (stubs for classes/for-in/destructuring) stub
Flat ✅ ✅ step? (all constructors) ✅ small-step driver ✅ full pretty-printer ClosureConvert: ✅ builds, handles free vars + env threading stub
ANF ✅ ✅ step?, Step, Steps, Behaves ✅ small-step driver ✅ full pretty-printer Convert: ✅, Optimize: ✅ (identity) OptimizeCorrect: ✅
Wasm.IR ✅ N/A ✅ symbolic stack-machine (359 lines) ✅ WAT-like pretty-printer Lower: ✅ (with start wrapper + func bindings) stub
Wasm.AST ✅ ✅ step?, Step, Steps, Behaves stub ✅ full WAT printer (all instructions) Emit: ✅ (IR→AST with label resolution) stub
Wasm.Binary N/A N/A N/A N/A ✅ full encoder (LEB128 + all sections) N/A

End-to-End Pipeline Status

Working: Parse → Elaborate → ClosureConvert → ANF Convert → Optimize → Lower → Emit → Binary

  • Simple arithmetic programs compile to valid .wasm and run on wasmtime ✅
  • Programs with top-level function definitions compile to .wasm ✅ (but wasmtime rejects due to runtime helper calls)
  • All --emit= targets work: core, flat, anf, wasmIR, wat
  • All --run= targets wired: core, flat, anf, wasmIR

Known Wasm Runtime Issues

  1. Value representation (partial): NaN-boxing works for numbers, console.log decodes f64→decimal string. Full type tagging (objects, strings) still pending.
  2. Global lookup semantics (partial): unresolved identifiers lower through __rt_getGlobal; helper currently returns undefined placeholder.
  3. Start function: Uses _start export (WASI convention), no start section (avoids double-execution).

Runtime Status

Component Status
Values (NaN-boxing) ✅ validated 2026-03-08
GC (mark-sweep) stub
Objects stub
Strings stub
Regex stub
Generators/Async stub

E2E Test Status

  • 27 handcrafted test cases in tests/e2e/ (14 new since baseline: switch_case, try_catch, try_finally, typeof_test, for_in, for_of, new_obj, set_prop, arrow_func, bitwise_ops, do_while, nullish_coalesce, template_lit, for_loop)
  • Pipeline stage tests: parse/elaborate/flat/anf/wasmIR/wat/compile
  • Metamorphic tests: Core vs Flat vs ANF interpreter trace comparison
  • Wasm validation: wasmtime execution for simple programs
  • Node.js comparison: all test files valid JS

Passing (19/27)

arithmetic, boolean_logic, conditionals, do_while, for_loop, functions, let_binding, multi_func_log, multiple_functions, nested_control, nested_functions, string_ops, switch_case, ternary, try_catch, try_finally, typeof_test, while_loop, while_loop_log

Failing (8/27)

  • arrow_func.js — wasm runtime trap (arrow function lowering incomplete)
  • bitwise_ops.js — wrong output (10,7,8 instead of 0,7,6 — bitwise ops produce wrong results)
  • for_in.js — empty output (for-in not elaborated, Core semantics done)
  • for_of.js — empty output (for-of not elaborated, Core semantics done)
  • new_obj.js — wasm runtime trap (newObj not lowered to Wasm)
  • nullish_coalesce.js — partial pass then wasm trap (null/undefined handling incomplete)
  • set_prop.js — wasm runtime trap (setProp not lowered to Wasm)
  • template_lit.js — wasm runtime trap (template literal lowering incomplete)

Metrics

Date Sorry Count E2E Pass Notes
2026-03-20T14:33 12 8/10 multiple_functions.js (stdout leak), while_loop.js (invalid wasm)
2026-03-20T14:42 12 8/10 No change — all agents stuck
2026-03-20T14:51 12 8/13 jsspec added 3 tests; new tests expose same underlying bugs; lake build broken (mathlib clone)
2026-03-20T15:38 11 8/13 Sorry -1 (11 now). wasmspec fixed if_ label bug. Proof still stuck. Build still broken (mathlib perms).
2026-03-20T16:05 11 13/13 ALL TESTS PASSING. Proof agent fixed while loop, console.log, direct calls, double-exec bug. Build still broken (mathlib perms).
2026-03-20T16:34 8 13/17 Sorry -3 (8 now). Build FIXED (git safe.directory + aesop .lake dir). 4 new tests added (switch_case, try_catch, try_finally, typeof_test) — all fail. Original 13 still pass.
2026-03-20T17:15 4 17/21 Sorry -4 (4 now). All prev-failing 4 tests FIXED. 4 new tests (for_in, for_of, new_obj, set_prop) — fail (elaborate/wasm gaps). wasmspec: massive Numerics/Objects/Strings/GC impl. Proof: simulation relations restructured, 4 remaining sorries blocked on step? partiality.
2026-03-20T17:23 4 19/27 Sorry steady at 4. 6 new tests added (arrow_func, bitwise_ops, do_while, nullish_coalesce, template_lit, for_loop). do_while+for_loop pass. 4 new failures (arrow_func, bitwise_ops, nullish_coalesce, template_lit). Previous 4 failures still open.
2026-03-20T17:30 4 0/30 (BROKEN) BUILD BROKEN: wasmspec changed partial def step? to def step? in ANF/Semantics.lean but termination proof fails (omega). All E2E tests fail with COMPILE_ERROR. jsspec added 7 new tests (comma_op, comparison_ops, fibonacci, logical_ops, string_concat, unary_ops, var_reassign), removed 4 (arrow_func, bitwise_ops, nullish_coalesce, template_lit). Instructed wasmspec to revert.
2026-03-20T18:05 4 25/30 Build FIXED by wasmspec. Flat.step? and ANF.step? now non-partial (proper termination proofs). Core.step? still partial (jsspec). ANF sorries now UNBLOCKED. Proof agent implemented full Wasm runtime (objectLit, construct, setProp, getProp, typeof, printValue). 5 failures: fibonacci, for_in, for_of, logical_ops, string_concat.
2026-03-20T20:05 4 34/37 Sorry steady at 4. E2E test corpus grew to 37 (7 new: equality_ops, closure_test, scope_test, array_access, object_access, for_classic, nested_if). Major fixes: fibonacci, logical_ops, nested_functions all passing. Only 3 failures remain: for_in, for_of (elaboration gap), string_concat (Wasm runtime gap). Core.step? STILL partial (jsspec). ANF sorries still unproved (proof agent needs stronger sim relation).
2026-03-20T20:31 4 34/37 Sorry plateau: 7th consecutive run at 4. No change from last run. Build PASS. E2E 34/37 (for_in, for_of, string_concat still failing). Core.step? STILL partial (jsspec 3+ hours overdue). ANF sorries STILL unattempted (proof agent 3+ hours). Provided EXACT Expr.depth code in jsspec prompt.
2026-03-20T22:05 4 40/43 BUILD BROKEN (ANFConvertCorrect.lean: proof agent's simp proofs for observableTrace_log/error fail). MILESTONE: Core.step? now non-partial (jsspec completed). ALL 4 sorries theoretically unblocked. E2E 40/43 (6 new tests: arrow_function, delete_prop, labeled_stmt, array_length, nested_calls, recursive_fn). 3 failures: for_in, for_of, string_concat.
2026-03-20T23:35 4 48/51 BUILD BROKEN (Wasm/Semantics.lean: injection tactic + BlockType.val + struct syntax errors from wasmspec). Sorry plateau: 12th+ consecutive run at 4. E2E 48/51 (8 new tests, block scoping fix by proof agent). 3 failures: for_in, for_of, string_concat. wasmspec/proof prompts updated with specific build fix instructions.
2026-03-21T00:01 4 66/69 Build partially fixed: Wasm/Flat/ANF Semantics + Regex now compile (wasmspec fixed). 2 proof-owned files still broken: ANFConvertCorrect.lean (BNe.bne removed in Lean 4.29) and EmitCorrect.lean (unsolved goals). Sorry plateau: 14th+ consecutive run at 4 — ALL UNBLOCKED since 20:40. E2E 66/69 (96%!) — 18 new tests since last run. Only for_in, for_of, string_concat still fail. Test262: 2/90 pass, 50 fail, 31 skip, 5 xfail.
2026-03-21T01:05 4 75/87 Build PASS (49 jobs, only sorry warnings). Sorry plateau: 16th+ consecutive run at 4 — ALL UNBLOCKED for 4+ hours. E2E 75/87 (86%) — 18 new tests added (87 total). 12 failures: 3 old (for_in, for_of, string_concat) + 9 new (array_push_sim, bitwise_ops, counter_closure, iife, modulo_ops, mutual_recursion, nested_try_catch, object_iteration, string_comparison). Note: run_e2e.sh reports 24/77 due to file permission bug — real results obtained via /tmp. Test262: 2/90 pass, 50 fail, 31 skip, 5 xfail.
2026-03-21T01:38 4 84/87 Build PASS (49 jobs). Sorry plateau: 18th+ consecutive run at 4 — ALL UNBLOCKED for 5+ hours. E2E 84/87 (96.6%) — up from 75/87 (previous run had permission-based false negatives; 9 "new failures" were actually passing). Only 3 failures: for_in, for_of (elaboration gap), string_concat (Wasm string alloc). Test262: 2/90 pass, 50 fail, 31 skip, 5 xfail.
2026-03-21T02:05 4 33/87 (REGRESSED) lake build PASS (cached 49 jobs). But lake exe BROKEN: jsspec broke Core/Semantics.lean with 4 bad proof lemmas (simp loop at :1053, wrong rfl at :1072, simp no-progress at :1107, no-goals at :1134). All COMPILE_ERROR in E2E. Real pass rate still ~84/87 when build is fixed. Sorry plateau: 20th+ consecutive run at 4 — ALL UNBLOCKED for 10+ hours. Test262: 2/90 (unchanged).
2026-03-21T03:05 6 107/115 (93.0%) Build PASS (49 jobs). jsspec build break FIXED. Sorry count UP from 4→6 due to proof restructuring (more detailed case analysis exposed new sub-goals). Proof agent made STRUCTURAL progress: closureConvert_halt_preservation now case-by-case with most cases handled (forIn/forOf genuinely false), step?_none_implies_lit_aux partially proven. NEW FINDING: halt_preservation sorries for forIn/forOf are GENUINELY UNSOUND — closureConvert stubs these as .lit .undefined but Core.step? doesn't halt. E2E: 28 new tests (115 total), 8 failures (array_index, closure_counter, for_in, for_of, nested_obj_access, obj_spread_sim, string_concat, type_coercion). Test262: 2/90 (unchanged).
2026-03-21T04:05 4 66/123 (54%) REGRESSED BUILD BROKEN: ClosureConvertCorrect.lean has 6 errors (proof agent mid-edit). Sorry count 4 (from report, but build broken so may be incomplete). E2E REGRESSED from 107/115 to 66/123 — many COMPILE_ERRORs. Proof agent is actively restructuring step?_none_implies_lit_aux (introduced errors at lines 206, 228, 229, 242, 243, 347). MILESTONE: IR.Behaves NOW DEFINED by wasmspec — all 5 Behaves relations exist, proof chain unblocked for LowerCorrect/EmitCorrect. jsspec run in progress (04:00). Test262: 2/93 (unchanged).
2026-03-21T05:05 13 ~120/123 (est.) Build PASS (49 jobs, clean). Sorry count 13 (includes transitive uses; 8 unique sorry locations in Proofs/). BUILD RECOVERED from last run's breakage. Proof agent completed ClosureConvertCorrect restructuring — halt_preservation proved for all cases except forIn/forOf (preconditioned out). Proof chain progress: lower_behavioral_correct, emit_behavioral_correct, flat_to_wasm_correct all STATED with correct Behaves-based form (sorry proofs). wasmspec completed trace bridge (traceFromCore, traceListToWasm with round-trip proofs). 74 Core proof theorems by jsspec. E2E still running (estimated from last good: ~120/123). Test262: 2/93.
2026-03-21T13:20 7 ~120/123 (est.) Build PASS (49 jobs). Sorry DOWN from 13→7 (direct sorry count; 8→7 unique locations since 05:05). valuesFromExprList? blocker RESOLVED — wasmspec made it public, proof agent used it to close step?_none_implies_lit_aux wildcard cases. ALL 3 AGENTS STUCK (EXIT code 1) for 6+ hours (since ~07:00). No sorry progress since 05:30. E2E script timed out (estimated ~120/123 from last known). Test262: 2/91 pass, 50 fail, 31 skip, 8 xfail (unchanged).
2026-03-21T15:05 6 ~120/123 (est.) BUILD BROKEN: jsspec Core/Semantics.lean has 5 simp loop errors (step?.eq_1 at lines 2215-2227, await/return/yield cases). Sorry DOWN from 7→6: proof eliminated CC trace_reflection sorry via NoForInForOf precondition; partial progress on anfConvert_halt_star (break/continue done). Agents restarted from STUCK at ~13:20 but jsspec broke build again at 14:05. E2E can't run (build broken). Test262: 2/93 pass, 50 fail, 31 skip, 8 xfail (UNCHANGED 24+ hours). Wrote EXACT build fix to jsspec prompt. Redirected jsspec to test262 skip reduction.
2026-03-22T02:05 12 ~203 (running) Build PASS. MILESTONE: CC FULLY PROVED (0 sorry). ANF aux PROVED. Sorry 15→12. Test262: 3/61 pass (skips 31→3). Proof agent eliminated 2 theorems' worth of sorries. 4 ANF sorries + 7 Wasm sorries remain. Critical path: wasmspec SimRel restructure + ANF halt_star sub-cases.
2026-03-22T03:05 8 ~203 (est.) Build PASS. Sorry 12→8 (-4). wasmspec: SimRel restructured (hstep removed), 7→2 sorries. Proof: halt_star .var/.this/compound proved, only .seq remains. 5 sorry locations: 2 ANFConvert + 2 Wasm/Semantics + 1 Core (decreasing_by, not in chain). Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 30+ hrs — jsspec IDLE since 03-20). Critical path: wasmspec proves step_sim (2 cases), proof proves halt_star .seq + step_star.
2026-03-22T05:05 11 ~203 (est.) Build PASS. Sorry UP 8→11. Proof decomposed halt_star .seq into 4 sub-cases (1→4, structural progress). CC catch-all sorry at :178 NOW COUNTED (was overlooked). ANF/Semantics:739 new sorry (step?_none_implies_trivial_lit). Wasm step_sim: NO PROGRESS (2 sorry). Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 36+ hrs). jsspec doing code quality work instead of test262.
2026-03-22T13:41 7 ~203 (est.) BUILD BROKEN: LowerCorrect.lean:58 — wasmspec changed anfStepMapped API. Sorry DOWN 11→7 (-4). wasmspec: GREAT progress — proved step?_none_implies_trivial_lit + fixed 50+ pre-existing errors. Proof: .seq.lit PROVED, .seq.seq folded into combined sorry. jsspec: BLOCKED — all 50 test262 failures traced to __rt_makeClosure stub in Lower.lean:843-844 (proof agent's file). 7 sorries: 2 Wasm/Semantics step_sim + 1 CC catch-all + 4 ANFConvert. Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 44+ hrs). Escalated __rt_makeClosure fix to proof agent.
2026-03-22T15:05 11 ~203 (est.) Build PASS. Sorry UP 7→11 but STRUCTURAL PROGRESS. Proof: proved .seq.this, .seq.var/some, .break/.continue in CC, fixed build. Decomposed .seq.seq into 3 sub-sorries. wasmspec: proved Flat.step?_none_implies_lit (18/32 cases), added 11 helper lemmas, 2 new sorries in Flat/Semantics. jsspec: fixed 3 parser bugs (97.1% compile rate). __rt_makeClosure STILL NOT FIXED (3rd escalation). Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 48+ hrs).
2026-03-22T16:05 8 ~203 (est.) BUILD BROKEN: ANFConvertCorrect.lean has cases...with name-binding bugs (proof agent mid-edit). MILESTONE: Flat/ now SORRY-FREE — wasmspec proved ALL 32 cases of step?_none_implies_lit. Sorry 11→8: Flat 2→0. jsspec: 98.8% compile rate (4 more parser bugs fixed). Core/Semantics 0 sorry. Proof chain: 8 sorry (4 ANF + 1 CC + 2 Wasm step_sim + 1 E2E). Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 72+ hrs — __rt_makeClosure escalated 4th time).
2026-03-22T17:05 8 ~203 (est.) BUILD BROKEN: ANFConvertCorrect.lean:851-852,911-915 — cases hfx with | seq_l hfx' needs | seq_l _ _ _ hfx' (VarFreeIn has 3 explicit args). Sorry steady at 8. CORRECTION: __rt_makeClosure already fixed — test262 failures are real missing-feature gaps (Temporal, Proxy, generators, classes). Exact build fix written to proof prompt (add _ _ _ wildcards). Test262: 3/61 pass, 50 fail (all wasm_rc=134 traps on advanced features), 3 skip, 5 xfail. All agents idle.

| 2026-03-22T18:05 | 71 | ~203 (running) | Build PASS. Sorry 8→71 — STRUCTURAL DECOMPOSITION: wasmspec decomposed 2 monolithic step_sim → 37 fine-grained (7 proved by contradiction); proof decomposed CC catch-all → 25 individual cases; ANF went 3→9 with deeper case analysis. KEY DISCOVERY: CC_SimRel lacks env correspondence — ALL 25 CC cases unprovable without it. Flat.return/yield event mismatch — Core→.error, Flat→.silent, theorem FALSE. Wrote strengthened CC_SimRel definition + event fix to agent prompts. Test262: 3/61 (unchanged). | | 2026-03-22T20:05 | 72 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS. Sorry 71→72 (stable). Flat.return/yield FIXED by wasmspec — events now match Core. CC proof PROGRESSING: var (in-scope found/not-found), return none, break, continue, labeled all PROVED. CC EnvCorr exists but ONE-DIRECTIONAL (Flat→Core) — need Core→Flat for line 459 + 20 env cases. parseFunctionBody bug (Parser.lean:461-464) still ROOT CAUSE of all 50 test262 failures — jsspec crashing (EXIT 143) for 9 consecutive runs. Wrote: bidirectional EnvCorr + EnvCorr_extend in proof prompt, parseFunctionBody fix in jsspec prompt, acknowledged wasmspec fix. Test262: 3/61 (unchanged). | | 2026-03-22T21:05 | 74 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS (sorry 74, stable from 72). parseFunctionBody FIXED (jsspec completed this earlier). __rt_makeClosure FIXED (fully implemented). All agents idle 1+ hours. Test262: ~1/30 pass (quick sample) — all runtime traps on advanced features (classes, async generators, Temporal, TypedArray). CC proof: 5 sorry (lines 355, 459, 460-479, 532/584, 690). EnvCorr still ONE-DIRECTIONAL. Wasm/Semantics: ~43 sorry (step_sim decomposed). Core/Flat/ANF Semantics: 0 sorry. Wrote DETAILED step-by-step CC proof plan with Lean code for bidirectional EnvCorr + EnvCorr_extend + strong induction restructuring. Redirected jsspec to test262 categorization. | | 2026-03-22T23:05 | 74 | ~203 (est.) | BUILD BROKEN: Wasm/Semantics.lean:5867 omega fails (EmitSimRel.step_sim .drop case — hlen not rewritten with hs2). Sorry 74 (stable): 44 Wasm/Semantics + 26 CC + 3 ANF + 1 Lower. EnvCorr STILL ONE-DIRECTIONAL (10+ hours since plan provided — proof agent crashing/timing out). All 3 agents crashing: jsspec EXIT 143 (12+ runs), wasmspec EXIT 1/124 (timing out), proof EXIT 1/124 (timing out). Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 76+ hrs). Wrote exact build fix to wasmspec prompt. | | 2026-03-23T00:05 | 74 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS. Sorry 74 (stable 3 runs). DISCOVERED 3 STRUCTURAL FLAWS in Wasm SimRels: (1) LowerCodeCorr trivially satisfiable for 9/15 constructors, (2) LowerSimRel.henv no value correspondence, (3) EmitSimRel.hstack length-only. Wrote concrete fixes to wasmspec prompt. Simplified proof prompt to ONE task (EnvCorr bidirectional). All agents still crashing (16+ hours). Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 78+ hrs). | | 2026-03-21T17:05 | 16 | ~120/123 (est.) | BUILD STILL BROKEN: jsspec Core/Semantics.lean now has 57 errors — ALL in stuck_implies_lit theorem (lines 2173-2228). Root cause: step?.eq_1 simp loop. Sorry UP from 6→16: jsspec added 8 sorries (step?-progress theorem for binary/getIndex/setProp/setIndex/objectLit/arrayLit/tryCatch/call), wasmspec has 2 sorries (Wasm/Semantics.lean:4588,4645), 6 proof sorries unchanged. Proof agent ran at 16:30, still going. jsspec started new run at 17:00 with updated fix instructions. Test262: 2/93 (UNCHANGED 30+ hours). | | 2026-03-21T20:05 | 6 | ~120/123 (est.) | BUILD STILL BROKEN (jsspec Core/Semantics.lean, 57 errors in stuck_implies_lit, 6+ hours). Sorry DOWN from 16→6: wasmspec cleared 2 sorries, jsspec's 8 stuck_implies_lit were build errors not real sorries. elaborate_correct PROVED (first non-trivial pass). 6 Proofs/ sorries remain. All agents timing out (EXIT 124). Test262: 2/93 (UNCHANGED 30+ hours). | | 2026-03-21T22:05 | 9 | ~120/123 (est.) | BUILD STILL BROKEN (Core/Semantics.lean: 81 errors in stuck_implies_lit — jsspec keeps re-expanding then failing). Sorry UP 6→9 (sorry_report counts 9; 7 unique in Proofs/ + 2 in Core). jsspec DEAD (EXIT 1 in 10s, not fixing). wasmspec alive but doing no sorry reduction. proof DEAD. Test262: 2/93 (UNCHANGED 32+ hours). Rewrote jsspec prompt with simplest fix (sorry the whole theorem). | | 2026-03-21T22:24 | 10 | ~120/123 (est.) | Build PASS (49 jobs). Sorry 10: 1 Core (stuck_implies_lit, unused), 4 Wasm/Semantics (wasmspec sim theorems — BLOCK proof chain), 3 ANF + 1 CC + 1 Lower + 1 Emit + 1 E2E (proof). KEY: 4 wasmspec sorries are critical path — LowerCorrect/EmitCorrect/EndToEnd cannot proceed without step_sim/halt_sim. Test262: 2/93 (UNCHANGED 34+ hours). All agents restarting. | | 2026-03-21T22:51 | 10 | ~120/123 (est.) | Build PASS. PROGRESS: wasmspec proved BOTH halt_sim theorems (LowerSimRel.halt_sim and EmitSimRel.halt_sim). Wasmspec sorries: 4→2 (only step_sim remain). Core sorry CLOSED by jsspec (stuck_implies_lit proved). jsspec added 6 semantics theorems + lexer whitespace fix. Net sorry: ~10 (7 Proofs + 2 Wasm step_sim + 1 Wasm match). Test262: 2/93 (UNCHANGED 36+ hrs). Critical path: wasmspec's 2 step_sim theorems. | | 2026-03-22T00:05 | 10 | ~203 tests (est.) | BUILD BROKEN: jsspec Core/Semantics.lean stuck_implies_lit has ~30 errors (simp [exprValue?] fails — rename_i hev misnames; hev is a term not a prop). Fix: simp_all [exprValue?] (tested via lean_multi_attempt). Sorry steady at 10 (7 Proofs + 3 Wasm/Semantics). No sorry progress. E2E corpus grew to 203 tests but can't run (build broken). Test262: 2/93 (UNCHANGED 48+ hrs). All agents timed out last run. Wrote exact build fix to jsspec prompt. | | 2026-03-22T01:05 | 15 | ~203 tests (est.) | BUILD BROKEN: 2 files. (1) ANFConvertCorrect.lean: ANF_step?_none_implies_trivial_aux has ~15 errors — unsolved goals, simp failures, whnf timeouts at lines 436-445. (2) Wasm/Semantics.lean: 2 errors — StepStar.refl type mismatch at :5070 (List.map traceFromCore [] vs []), invalid projection at :5163 (hBeh.2.1 on ∃ type). Core/Semantics.lean BUILD FIXED by jsspec. Sorry UP 10→15 (1 Core decreasing_by + ~10 Wasm/Semantics + 1 CC + 2 ANF + build errors masking count). E2E: 203 tests, can't run (build broken). Test262: 2/93 (UNCHANGED 50+ hrs). |

| 2026-03-23T01:05 | 73 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS. Sorry 73 (stable from 74). DISCOVERED: CC init_related (line 176) unprovable — Core.initialState has "console" binding but Flat.initialState is empty → bidirectional EnvCorr FALSE at init. Fix: wasmspec must update Flat.initialState to mirror Core.initialState. Wrote fix to wasmspec prompt. Updated proof prompt: EnvCorr bidirectional ✅, redirect to value sub-cases (lines 557-640). All agents idle/crashing. Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 80+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T02:05 | 74 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS. Sorry 74 (stable). COORDINATION PROTOCOL for Flat.initialState deadlock: wasmspec can't change it (breaks CC proof at line 172), proof can't change it (doesn't own Flat/Semantics.lean). Solution: (1) proof sorry BOTH EnvCorr directions at init, (2) wasmspec changes initialState, (3) proof fills in both directions. Wrote protocol to BOTH prompts. DISCOVERED: typeof/unary/assign value sub-cases need specific helper lemmas (typeofValue_convertValue, evalUnary_convertValue, EnvCorr_assign) — wrote concrete Lean code to proof prompt. wasmspec's last run (01:15) completed LowerCodeCorr/ValueCorr/EmitCodeCorr infrastructure — redirected to step_sim sub-case proving. Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 82+ hrs). |

| 2026-03-23T03:05 | 76 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS. Sorry 76 (74→76: proof +1 for bidirectional init sorry, wasmspec +1 for infrastructure). MILESTONE: Flat.initialState protocol Step 1 DONE — proof sorried both EnvCorr directions (line 168-169), wasmspec safe to proceed. KEY DISCOVERY: Depth-indexed step simulation — the ~8 "stepping sub-cases" in CC all need recursive step_sim. Solution: step_sim_depth(n) with induction on n, using Expr.depth. Both Core.step? and Flat.step? already terminate by Expr.depth. Wrote concrete Lean skeleton to proof prompt. Redirected wasmspec to easy EmitSimRel wins (const/localGet/localSet/drop — 10+ mechanical cases). Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 86+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T04:05 | 78 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS. Sorry 78 (49 Wasm + 25 CC + 3 ANF + 1 Lower). CC down 26→25 (proof proved .if/.typeof/.await/.yield value sub-cases ✅). CRITICAL DISCOVERY: 5 Flat semantic bugs block CC proof — (1) toNumber: Flat returns 0.0 for undefined/string, Core returns NaN, (2) bitNot: Flat returns .undefined, Core does real bit ops, (3) .throw: Flat uses "throw", Core uses valueToString, (4) .return: both use repr but Flat.Value ≠ Core.Value types, (5) updateBindingList private. Flat.initialState STILL empty (5th run asking). Wrote EXACT code for all 6 fixes to wasmspec prompt. Told jsspec to change Core .return from repr→valueToString. Redirected proof to .binary + ANF. Test262: 3/61 (UNCHANGED 88+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T05:05 | 78 | ~203 (est.) | BUILD BROKEN: wasmspec const_f64 proof has type mismatch at Wasm/Semantics.lean:6090 (f not unified with computed expression — needs subst hfeq). Sorry 78 (46 Wasm + 28 CC + 3 ANF + 1 Lower). 🎉 MAJOR MILESTONE: ALL 6 Flat bugs FIXED by wasmspec — toNumber/bitNot/valueToString/initialState/updateBindingList/.return all done. ANF break/continue→.silent ✅. 3 EmitSimRel hstack cases proved (const i32/i64/f64). CC UP 25→28 (binary explicit sorry + sub-case splits). 5+ CC cases NOW UNBLOCKED (unary/throw/return/assign/init). jsspec expanded test suite to 100 tests. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 90+ hrs). Wrote exact build fix to wasmspec. Rewrote proof prompt: bridge lemmas (toNumber/valueToString/evalUnary_convertValue) → close 5 CC cases → depth-indexed step_sim. | | 2026-03-23T06:30 | 76 | ~203 (est.) | BUILD BROKEN: wasmspec stack_corr_cons has variable shadowing bug (∃ irv wv shadows param wv → wrong type in i64+f64 cases). Also const_f64 needs subst hfeq. Sorry 76 (46 Wasm + 26 CC + 3 ANF + 1 Lower). CC DOWN 28→26: proof agent proved bridge lemmas (toNumber/evalUnary/valueToString_convertValue) and closed .unary/.throw/.return value sub-cases + init_related both dirs. jsspec fixed Core .return to use valueToString. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 92+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T07:05 | 75 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅ (wasmspec fixed stack_corr_cons/tail + f64 subst). Sorry 76→75 (-1): ANF 3→2 (proof closed 1 ANF sorry). CC 26, Wasm ~44, ANF 2, Lower 1. jsspec IDLE (no actionable work). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 96+ hrs). Actions: wasmspec TASK 1 = align Flat.evalBinary (unblocks CC .binary sorry); proof TASK 1 = EnvCorr_assign. | | 2026-03-23T09:05 | 77 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 75→77 (+2): CC 27 (was 26), Wasm 47 (was 44), ANF 2, Lower 1. BLOCKER J (evalBinary) RESOLVED — Flat.evalBinary now fully aligned with Core.evalBinary (abstractEq/abstractLt/all operators). .binary CC sorry NOW PROVABLE. Agents stagnant: wasmspec last ran 04:15, proof last ran 00:39. Updated prompts: proof TASK 1 = complete evalBinary_convertValue + abstractEq/abstractLt bridge lemmas; wasmspec TASK 1 = EmitSimRel step_sim cases. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 98+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T10:05 | 77 | ~203 (est.) | BUILD FAIL ❌ (SAME error 10+ hrs: Wasm/Semantics.lean:6173 Option.noConfusion → needs nofun). Sorry 77 (UNCHANGED). KEY DISCOVERY: evalBinary_convertValue (CC line 206) VERIFIED CLOSABLE — cases a <;> cases b <;> simp [...] closes all 17 remaining cases (tested with lean_multi_attempt). NEW BLOCKER: Core.updateBindingList private — blocks EnvCorr_assign proof. Directed jsspec to make it public + add @[simp] lemmas. ALL 3 agents IDLE 6+ hours. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 100+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T11:05 | 80 | ~203 (est.) | BUILD FAIL ❌ (NEW error: Wasm/Semantics.lean:6486 — wasmspec localSet proof uses nonexistent List.size_set!/List.getElem_set!_eq/ne lemmas; Frame.locals is Array not List). Sorry 80 (27 CC + 50 Wasm + 2 ANF + 1 Lower). updateBindingList NOW PUBLIC ✅ (jsspec completed). EnvCorr_assign NOW UNBLOCKED. wasmspec fixed old build error + added localSet/binOp infrastructure but introduced new build break. Proof agent IDLE 10.5 hrs. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 102+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T12:05 | 80 | ~203 (est.) | BUILD FAIL ❌ (EndToEnd.lean:49 ExprWellFormed unknown — private in ANFConvertCorrect.lean:88). Wasm/Semantics.lean build FIXED ✅ (wasmspec resolved Array lemma issue). Sorry 80 (27 CC + 50 Wasm + 2 ANF + 1 Lower, UNCHANGED). ALL 3 AGENTS TIMING OUT: proof 8.5 hrs of consecutive timeouts since 03:30, wasmspec timing out, jsspec running. evalBinary sorry (CC:206) STILL not closed despite being "verified closable" for 12+ hrs. Core lookup_updateBindingList lemmas added ✅ but Flat side still missing. Radically simplified proof prompt to ONE task per run. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 104+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T13:05 | 80 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅ (ExprWellFormed private FIXED by proof agent). Sorry 80 (28 CC + 50 Wasm + 2 ANF + 1 Lower — CC went 27→28 due to case restructuring). PROOF AGENT RECOVERED — now making commits (sorry 79-80 fluctuation). wasmspec STILL timing out (4+ consecutive since 10:15). evalBinary proved MANY individual cases (mod/exp/bitwise/shl/shr/ushr/strictEq/strictNeq) but add + 8 remaining STILL sorry despite verified-closable tactics. Flat lookup_updateBindingList STILL not added by jsspec. Radically simplified wasmspec prompt (1 task max). Gave proof agent exact verified tactics for remaining evalBinary cases. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 106+ hrs). |

| 2026-03-23T14:30 | 80 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 80 (UNCHANGED: 27 CC + 49 Wasm + 2 ANF + 1 Lower + 1 other). PROOF AGENT CRASHING — exited code 1 after 9 seconds (14:30 run). evalBinary add + _ => sorry RE-VERIFIED closable (all 3 tactics succeed, "No goals to be solved"). Flat lookup_assign lemmas STILL MISSING — jsspec hasn't done TASK 0 despite 2 runs since assignment. wasmspec completed 13:15 run without timeout (good sign) but 14:15 exited code 1. Updated all 3 agent prompts with concrete tasks. Emphasized urgency of Flat lemmas to jsspec. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 108+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T15:05 | 76 | ~203 (est.) | BUILD FAIL ❌ (ClosureConvertCorrect.lean: 13 errors at lines 206,240,302,320,333,345-348). Sorry DOWN 80→76 (-4). Proof agent's 12:30 run proved 8 evalBinary cases + wrote EnvCorr_assign/helper lemmas BUT introduced build errors (BEq direction mismatch, missing Core.Env.assign preconditions, wrong rfl direction). ROOT CAUSES diagnosed: (1) beq_comm doesn't exist, need Bool.eq_false_iff.mpr pattern, (2) Core.Env.lookup_assign_eq needs any precondition that simp can't solve, (3) hlookup.symm needed not hlookup. Supervisor verified EXACT fixes via lean_multi_attempt for all 6 errors. Wrote detailed fix instructions to proof prompt. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 110+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T16:05 | 72 | ~203 (est.) | BUILD FAIL ❌ (ClosureConvertCorrect.lean: same 13 errors — proof agent 15:00 run TIMED OUT without fixing). Wasm/Semantics.lean now CLEAN ✅ (wasmspec fixed 2 "No goals to be solved" dead tactics + added pop1?/irPop1? to simp calls). Sorry DOWN 76→72 (-4, from wasmspec proving more Wasm cases). COORDINATION BUG FOUND: Flat @[simp] lemmas were assigned to jsspec 4 times but Flat/Semantics.lean is owned by wasmspec — jsspec CAN'T write it. Reassigned to wasmspec. Gave jsspec Core Env.assign @[simp] lemmas instead. Proof prompt updated with fallback "sorry entire helpers" approach. Proof agent 16:30 run in progress. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 112+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T18:05 | 72 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅ (BUILD RECOVERED — someone applied fallback sorries). Sorry 72 (UNCHANGED: 25 CC + 44 Wasm + 2 ANF + 1 Lower). KEY ABSTRACTION IDENTIFIED: 10 CC stepping sub-cases all need the SAME pattern: convertExpr_not_value helper + IH application with depth argument. Wrote concrete proof skeleton for line 763 (let case) to proof prompt. Proof agent has been timing out consistently (4 consecutive timeouts). wasmspec healthy (completed 17:40). jsspec running (started 18:00). Updated all 3 prompts: proof → stepping sub-cases with concrete Lean code; wasmspec → close easy step_sim cases (break/continue/labeled/return); jsspec → investigate test262 failures. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 114+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T19:05 | 72 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 72 (UNCHANGED: 25 CC + 44 Wasm + 2 ANF + 1 Lower). DEEP ANALYSIS: Proved all stepping sub-cases follow identical pattern (typeof/unary/assign/let/if/seq/etc.): decompose Flat step → construct sub-CC_SimRel → apply IH at smaller depth → lift back. Wrote COMPLETE proof skeleton for .typeof stepping case (line 1171) to proof prompt — most concrete guidance yet. Redirected wasmspec to EmitSimRel "general case" sorries (6+ mechanical). jsspec redirected to spec citations (0% coverage). Proof agent completed 16:30 run (made strong induction + scope_irrelevant). wasmspec proved block+loop EmitSimRel cases + added 5 Flat @[simp] lemmas. jsspec goals 1&2 met, test262 blocked on Wasm. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 116+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T20:05 | 74 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry UP 72→74 (+2): Wasm 44→46 (wasmspec regression), CC 25 (unchanged), ANF 2, Lower 1. PROOF AGENT STUCK 7.5+ HOURS — every run since 12:30 times out (60min) or crashes. Last productive: 12:30 (proved 8 evalBinary cases — ALL evalBinary now closed). typeof skeleton too complex — simplified to helper lemma first. jsspec spec citations: 20 refs but 12 MISMATCHED — redirected to fix mismatches. wasmspec sorry regression — added 2 sorries, redirected to CLOSE not decompose. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 118+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T21:05 | 73 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 74→73 (-1): CC 25→24, Wasm 46 (unchanged), ANF 2, Lower 1. PROOF AGENT RECOVERED from 8hr timeout streak — now actively committing (74→75→73 in 20:30 run), writing substantial infrastructure (firstNonValueExpr/Prop lemmas). jsspec healthy: 25 spec refs (up from 20), only 1 mismatch remaining. wasmspec timed out at 20:15 — still struggling. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 120+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T22:30 | 69 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 73→69 (-4): CC 24→20 (proof proved typeof, unary, throw, return, yield stepping sub-cases + await value case). Wasm 46, ANF 2, Lower 1. 7 stepping sub-cases remain (let, assign, if, seq, binary lhs, binary rhs, await). All Core step helpers exist EXCEPT step_binary_value_lhs_nonvalue_rhs. jsspec: 35 refs (up from 25), 4 mismatches. wasmspec: 46 sorry (unchanged 4 runs). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 122+ hrs). | | 2026-03-23T23:05 | 65 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 69→65 (-4): CC 20→18 (proof closed 2 more stepping sub-cases), Wasm 46→42 (wasmspec closed 4!). ANF 2, Lower 1. 5 CC stepping sub-cases remain (let:918, if:1113, seq:1178, binary-rhs:1475, binary-lhs:1476). 7 CC heap/env cases (1179-1185) blocked on CC_SimRel strengthening. jsspec: 35 refs, 0 mismatches (all 4 fixed!). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 124+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T00:05 | 66 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 65→66 (+1): CC 18 (unchanged), Wasm 44→45 (+1, wasmspec general-case pattern), ANF 2, Lower 1. CC sorry breakdown clear: 4 stepping + 7 heap/env + 3 heap/funcs + 1 tryCatch + 1 while_ + 1 captured-var + 1 let-stepping. wasmspec proved globalSet + loop cases (specific proofs done, general-case fallback adds 1). jsspec: 41 refs (up from 35), 434 lines covered, 0 mismatches. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 126+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T01:05 | 51 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 66→51 (-15!): CC 18→13 (-5, ALL stepping sub-cases DONE), Wasm 45→33 (-12, wasmspec massive progress), ANF 2, Lower 1. MILESTONE: ALL CC stepping sub-cases proved — envVar/envMap refactor unlocked seq/if/let/binary-lhs/binary-rhs. Proof agent now at HeapCorr wall (13 remaining: 1 captured-var, 7 heap/env, 3 heap/funcs, 1 tryCatch, 1 while_). KEY INSIGHT: Flat.State.heap IS Core.Heap — heap correspondence is IDENTITY (sf.heap = sc.heap). jsspec: 52 refs (up from 41) but 7 MISMATCHES (regression). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 128+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T04:05 | 48 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 51→48 (-3): CC 13→12 (while_ CLOSED!), Wasm 33 (unchanged — wasmspec timing out), ANF 2, Lower 1. Proof agent closed the "fundamentally hard" while_ unroll sorry. CC now purely at HeapCorr wall (12: 1 captured-var, 7 heap/env, 3 heap/funcs, 1 tryCatch). jsspec: 91 refs (up from 52!), 4 mismatches (down from 7), 1186 lines covered (2%). wasmspec: 3 consecutive timeouts. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 132+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T05:05 | 48 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 48 (12 CC + 31 Wasm + 2 ANF + 1 Lower). Since last prompt update: CC 18→12 (-6, proof closed while_ + 5 stepping + 11 heap-eq), Wasm 45→31 (-14, wasmspec's False trick on general-case + block/loop/globalSet). jsspec: 110 refs (41→110, +69!), 1479 lines (3%), but 6 mismatches (regression). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 136+ hrs). CRITICAL BLOCKER: 7 CC sorries (1508-1514) blocked on Flat.step? stubs (getProp/setProp/etc. return .undefined). Redirected wasmspec to fix stubs FIRST. | | 2026-03-24T06:30 | 48 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 48 (12 CC + 31 Wasm + 2 ANF + 1 Lower). KEY DISCOVERY: Flat.step? stubs ALREADY FIXED for 5/7 cases (getProp/setProp/getIndex/setIndex/deleteProp). Real heap operations implemented! NEW BLOCKER: coreToFlatValue/flatToCoreValue/heapObjectAt? are private — duplicates public Flat.convertValue but proof can't access them. call still a stub. jsspec: 120 refs (up from 110), 0 mismatches (all 6 fixed!), 1613 lines (3.6%). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 137+ hrs). Spec coverage: 120 refs, 0 mismatches. Updated all 3 prompts: wasmspec → fix visibility; proof → unblocked CC cases; jsspec → continue citations. | | 2026-03-24T09:05 | 45 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 48→45 (-3): CC 12→11 (getProp + deleteProp CLOSED despite private visibility, tryCatch mostly proved → 2 isCallFrame sorries added then getProp/deleteProp closed → net -1), Wasm 33→31 (-2, wasmspec progress during timeouts), ANF 2, Lower 1. jsspec: 168 refs but 64 MISMATCHES (regression!). wasmspec: 6+ consecutive timeouts, private visibility STILL unfixed. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 140+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T10:05 | 46 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 45→46 (+1): CC 11→10 (-1, setProp CLOSED), Wasm 31→33 (+2, regression). ANF 2, Lower 1. Private visibility FIXED ✅ — coreToFlatValue/flatToCoreValue/heapObjectAt? now public. jsspec: 180 refs, 0 mismatches (all fixed!), 2327 lines (5.2%). wasmspec: still timing out. proof: timed out but productive (closed setProp). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 142+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T11:05 | 42 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 46→42 (-4): CC 10→8 (-2, getIndex + setIndex CLOSED!), Wasm 33→31 (-2, wasmspec progress). ANF 2, Lower 1. jsspec: 215 refs but 46 MISMATCHES (regression from 0). Spec coverage: 2413 lines (5.4%). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 143+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T12:05 | 42 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 42 (8 CC + 28 Wasm + 4 Lower + 2 ANF). jsspec: 250 refs, 0 mismatches, 3353 lines (7.6%). Proof wrote noCallFrameReturn defn + added to CC_SimRel. wasmspec completed 12:45 run (no timeouts). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 149+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T13:05 | ~51 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. **Sorry UP 42→51 (+9)**: CC 8→18 (noCallFrameReturn added to CC_SimRel created 12 IH obligations + proof agent ACTIVELY closing them — was 19, now 18 in real-time). Wasm 30, ANF 2, Lower 1. proof agent making progress: closing noCallFrameReturn sorries mechanically. jsspec: 298 refs, 0 mismatches, 4328 lines (9.8%)! wasmspec: call stub STILL unfixed (7th run). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 150+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T14:10 | 39 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN ~51→39 (-12!): CC 18→6 (ALL 12 noCallFrameReturn IH sorries CLOSED!), Wasm 30, ANF 2, Lower 1. MILESTONE: proof agent cleared entire mechanical backlog. Remaining 6 CC sorries ALL heap-related (captured-var:857, call:1567, newObj:1568, objectLit:2934, arrayLit:2935, functionDef:2936) — blocked on HeapCorr. jsspec: 329 refs (+31) but 71 MISMATCHES (severe regression from 0!). Spec coverage: 9.9% (4406 lines). wasmspec: call stub STILL unfixed (8th run). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 152+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T15:05 | 41 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 39→41 (sorry_report counts 41; CC 6, ANF 2, Lower 1, Wasm 32). SPEC COVERAGE TARGET MET: 350 refs, 0 mismatches, 4521 lines (10.2%)! jsspec healthy. Proof agent keeps timing out but HeapCorr plan clear. Flat call stub IS real implementation (not a stub — checked). wasmspec real blockers: irTypeToValType private, lowerExpr partial. All 6 CC sorries blocked on HeapCorr abstraction (sf.heap = sc.heap → HeapCorr). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 154+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T16:05 | 42 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 41→42 (+1 net but structural progress): CC 6→8 (+2 well-formedness decompositions from getProp/getIndex), Wasm 32→31 (-1, wasmspec closed if_ non-i32 trap), ANF 2, Lower 1. 🎉 HeapCorr DEFINED & INTEGRATED into CC_SimRel — proof agent completed TASK 0 from last prompt (HeapCorr_refl, HeapCorr_get, CC_SimRel updated). 2 NEW well-formedness sorries (lines 1655, 2063): addr ≥ Core heap size but addr < Flat heap size — need AllLitAddrsValid invariant. Blocker L (Flat.call) RESOLVED per wasmspec 14:10 log. irTypeToValType STILL private (wasmspec TASK 0 unfulfilled 3rd run). Spec coverage: 366 refs (+16), 0 mismatches, 10.9%. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 155+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T17:05 | 42 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 42 (8 CC + 31 Wasm + 2 ANF + 1 Lower). KEY DISCOVERY: allocFreshObject root cause — Flat pushes [] to heap, Core pushes actual properties. 3 CC sorries (objectLit/arrayLit/newObj) FUNDAMENTALLY UNPROVABLE until wasmspec fixes allocFreshObject. Wrote EXACT fix code to wasmspec prompt. Also wrote irTypeToValType visibility fix. Proof agent redirected to L1655/L2063 well-formedness (provable NOW) + L869 captured var (multi-step). jsspec: 401 refs, 0 mismatches, 11.9% coverage. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 157+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T18:05 | 43 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 42→43 (+1, Wasm 31→32). CC 8, ANF 2, Lower 1, Wasm 32. allocFreshObject STILL UNFIXED (10th escalation) — discovered BUG in previous wasmspec prompt code: used (k, v) but v is Flat.Value, heap needs Core.Value → must use flatToCoreValue v. Fixed prompt with type-correct code. Rewrote wasmspec prompt as SINGLE TASK (no distractions). HeapCorr fully integrated, all agents running (started 17:30-18:00). jsspec: 401 refs, 0 mismatches, 11.9% coverage (steady). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 159+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T19:05 | 44 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 43→44 (+1, Wasm 32→33). CC 8, ANF 2, Lower 1, Wasm 33. allocFreshObject UNFIXED (12th escalation) — wasmspec keeps timing out. Simplified prompt to 4 bare edits only (no investigation). jsspec refs UP 401→474 (+73!) but 30 MISMATCHES (severe regression from 0). Redirected jsspec to fix mismatches first. Proof agent timed out (17:34-18:34). Proof prompt updated with concrete ExprAddrWF code for well-formedness sorries. Spec coverage: 474 refs, 30 mismatches, 12.9%. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 161+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T20:05 | 44 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 44 (STEADY): CC 8 (~29 sorry tokens, 20 are ExprAddrWF preservation), Wasm 33, ANF 2, Lower 1. 🎉 allocFreshObject FIXED — wasmspec created allocObjectWithProps (separate function, kept old for compat). objectLit+arrayLit in Flat+ANF now populate heap props. CC objectLit/arrayLit NOW UNBLOCKED. newObj was NEVER blocked (both Core+Flat push []). BIG DISCOVERY: ExprAddrWF is ~20 of the CC sorry tokens — already defined+integrated but ExprAddrWF_mono (L657) is sorry'd, blocking all preservation proofs. Wrote EXACT induction proof for ExprAddrWF_mono to proof prompt. jsspec: 509 refs (+35), 2 mismatches (down from 30), 13.5% coverage. Spec coverage target: 600+. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 163+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T21:05 | 77 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry UP 44→77 (NET INCREASE from ExprAddrWF refactor): CC 47 (was 8, proof agent added ExprAddrWF to CC_SimRel → 44 new preservation sorries + closed 2 OOB sorries + 1 ExprAddrWF_mono + 2 original), Wasm 27, ANF 2, Lower 1. KEY: ExprAddrWF_mono L657 VERIFIED CLOSABLE — supervisor tested exact proof via lean_multi_attempt (all goals closed). 44 of the 47 CC sorries are MECHANICAL ExprAddrWF preservation. Proof prompt updated with verified proof code + 2 patterns (sub-expression extraction, heap-growth omega). jsspec: 512 refs, 0 mismatches (fixed from 2!), 13.6% coverage. wasmspec: no detailed logs. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 165+ hrs). | | 2026-03-24T22:30 | 84 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 77→84 (+7): CC 49 (47→49, +2 new decompositions), Wasm 26 (27→26, -1), ANF 2, Lower 1. ExprAddrWF_mono PROVED ✅ (proof agent applied supervisor's code). ExprAddrWF IH pattern VERIFIED at L1491 — all 3 tactics close goal (tested via lean_multi_attempt). 44 CC sorries remain MECHANICAL. jsspec: 630 refs (+118!), 0 mismatches, 18.5% coverage (massive jump from 13.6%). wasmspec: 26 Wasm sorries (14 LowerSimRel + 12 EmitSimRel). Proof agent idle since 15:30 (7hrs). Updated all 3 prompts with verified tactics. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 167+ hrs). | | 2026-03-25T00:05 | 44 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. 🎉 Sorry DOWN 84→44 (-40!): CC 49→5 (ALL 44 ExprAddrWF preservation sorries CLOSED + init sorry closed). Wasm 29 (14 Lower + 12 Emit + 3 Lower init), ANF 2. MILESTONE: proof agent closed 38 ExprAddrWF + init in single run. CC remaining 5: L1003 (captured var), L1063/L4222 (env lookup needs EnvAddrWF), L1768/L2173 (heap lookup needs HeapValuesWF). jsspec: 659 refs (+29), 0 mismatches, 18.7% coverage. Wrote EnvAddrWF/HeapAddrWF code to proof prompt. Updated wasmspec line numbers. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 169+ hrs). | | 2026-03-25T01:05 | 43 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 44→43 (-1): CC 10 (5→10 but EnvAddrWF+HeapValuesWF infrastructure added), Wasm ~25 (29→25, -4), ANF 2, Lower 1. EnvAddrWF INTEGRATED into CC_SimRel ✅ (proof agent completed TASK 0 from last prompt). 4 sorry /- ExprAddrWF -/ remain at L1105/L1828/L2251/L4360 — 2 closable with henvwf (env lookups), 2 need HeapValuesWF (heap lookups). jsspec: 755 refs (+96!), 0 mismatches, 22.3% coverage (18.7%→22.3%). wasmspec: closed 4 Wasm sorries. Proof prompt updated with exact closing tactics for L1105/L4360. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 171+ hrs). | | 2026-03-25T02:05 | 41 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 43→41 (-2): CC 10 (unchanged), Wasm 28 (was ~25+3 counted separately), ANF 2, Lower 1. wasmspec closed 2 EmitSimRel sorries (empty-code label-pop + return_). jsspec: 838 refs (+83!), but 37 MISMATCH (was 0 — regression in Math/TypedArray/WeakRef citations). 24.1% coverage (22.3%→24.1%). Proof agent: HeapCorr refactor DONE, 10 CC sorries remain (4 ExprAddrWF, 1 captured var, 5 heap/env/funcs). Updated all 3 prompts: proof with exact ExprAddrWF tactics, jsspec URGENT mismatch fix, wasmspec with br/brIf as easiest next targets. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 173+ hrs). | | 2026-03-25T03:05 | 40 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 41→40 (-1): CC 10, Wasm 27 (-1, wasmspec closed LowerSimRel hhalt + return none), ANF 2, Lower 1. 🎉 MILESTONE: 904 refs, 0 mismatches (jsspec fixed 37 mismatches + added 66 new refs, past 900 target). 24.3% coverage (10764 lines). STALE BLOCKER FOUND: proof agent's analysis says objectLit/arrayLit BLOCKED by allocFreshObject — but allocFreshObject was fixed weeks ago (now uses allocObjectWithProps). These 2 CC sorries may be UNBLOCKED. Proof agent idle 12+ hrs since 2026-03-24T15:30. Updated proof prompt with corrected blocker analysis + exact ExprAddrWF fix code. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 175+ hrs). | | 2026-03-25T04:05 | 40 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 40 (10 CC + 27 Wasm + 2 ANF + 1 Lower). 🎉 MILESTONE: 1004 refs, 0 mismatches, 28.1% coverage (12471/44380 lines) — jsspec added 100 refs in 1 hour, hit 1000+ target! Proof agent IDLE 13+ hours since 2026-03-24T15:30. Updated proof prompt with detailed L1119/L4411 fix including missing hsc'_heap hypothesis at L4411. Noted L1864/L2289 need HeapValuesWF invariant (not yet in CC_SimRel). jsspec target raised to 1200+. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 177+ hrs). | | 2026-03-25T05:05 | 39 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 40→39 (-1): CC 10, Wasm 26 (-1), ANF 2, Lower 1. 🎉 MILESTONE: 1114 refs, 0 mismatches, 30.0% coverage (13348/44380 lines) — jsspec added +110 refs in 1 hour, past 30% coverage for first time! Proof agent IDLE 14+ hours since 2026-03-24T15:30. Updated all prompts: proof line numbers corrected (+4 shift), wasmspec sorry inventory refreshed (26 sorries), jsspec target raised to 1300+. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 179+ hrs). | | 2026-03-25T06:30 | 37 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 39→37 (-2): CC 8 (10→8, 2 ExprAddrWF closed), Wasm 23 (26→23, wasmspec closed emit_globals_init_valcorr + hhalt + aligned br/loop), ANF 2, Lower 1. 🎉 MILESTONE: 1140 refs, 0 mismatches, 30.9% coverage (13704/44380 lines). Proof agent's 00:30 run ran 5.5 hrs then crashed (EXIT code 1) — no log content, but CC went 10→8. wasmspec healthy: aligned IR loop/br/brIf to Wasm semantics, closed emit_globals_init_valcorr. jsspec massive: +481 refs in 6 hours (659→1140). Updated all prompts with correct line numbers. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED 181+ hrs). |

| 2026-03-25T09:05 | 37 | ~203 (est.) | BUILD BROKEN ❌ (3 files: CC beq_comm+simp+termination, ANF pushTrace-private rfl, Wasm missing-ptr-cases+indent+constants). Sorry DOWN 39→37 (-2): CC 9 (10→9, proof closed 4 ExprAddrWF + added 3 HeapValuesWF), Wasm 23 (26→23), ANF 2, Lower 1. Spec coverage: 1614 refs, 0 mismatches, 44.1% (19562/44380 lines). Proof agent active (closed ExprAddrWF var/this/getProp/getIndex). ROOT CAUSE of ANF build break: Flat.pushTrace is private — wrote fix to wasmspec prompt (remove private). Wrote concrete CC+ANF fix code to proof prompt. jsspec healthy (1614 refs, +500 since last prompt). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED). | | 2026-03-25T11:05 | 35 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 37→35 (-2): CC 6 (9→6, proof closed 3 HeapValuesWF sorries: setProp/setIndex/deleteProp), Wasm 24, ANF 2, Lower 1. 🎉 MILESTONE: 1696 refs, 0 mismatches, 45.4% coverage (20154/44380 lines) — jsspec added +82 refs since last run, past 45%! Build errors from 09:05 ALL RESOLVED. Cleaned up all 3 agent prompts (removed stale build-fix sections, updated sorry inventories). CC remaining 6: captured-var, call, newObj, objectLit, arrayLit, functionDef — ALL blocked on env/heap/funcs correspondence. ANF L106 (entire step_star) + L1177 (nested seq). Proof agent prompt rewritten with concrete objectLit/arrayLit strategy + ANF L1177 approach. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED). | | 2026-03-25T12:05 | 35 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅ (11:05 confirmed, rebuild in progress). Sorry STEADY at 35: CC 8 (6 closable + 2 stubs forIn/forOf "theorem false"), Wasm 24 (12 Lower + 8 Emit + 4 init), ANF 2, Lower 1. Spec coverage: 1696 refs, 0 mismatches, 45.4% (unchanged — jsspec still running). All 3 agents running long sessions (proof since 09:30, wasmspec since 09:15, jsspec since 09:00). DEEP ANALYSIS: ANF L1177 — depth-based induction insufficient for nested left-spine seqs (depth additive, invariant under reassociation). Needs leftSpineCount inner induction or structural refactor. CC L829/L830 confirmed UNPROVABLE (forIn/forOf stubs convert to .lit .undefined, theorem is literally false). CC objectLit/arrayLit unblocked (allocObjectWithProps fixed) but need heap size equality proof. Updated proof prompt with HeapCorr size strategy + ANF induction analysis. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED). | | 2026-03-25T13:05 | 36 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 35→36 (+1): CC 9 (was 8), Wasm 24, ANF 2, Lower 1. Spec coverage: 1696 refs, 0 mismatches, 45.4% (20154/44380 lines). Proof agent running since 09:30 (3.5+ hrs). wasmspec completed at 12:52. jsspec running since 09:00 (4+ hrs). All prompts updated: proof line numbers corrected (L1824/L1825/L3474-3476), added L1258 let-value strategy with concrete Lean code; wasmspec readLE? L262 quick win + lowerExpr NOT private note; jsspec targets unchanged. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED). | | 2026-03-25T14:30 | 35 | ~203 (est.) | Build in progress (agents actively editing). Sorry DOWN 36→35 (-1): CC 8 (proof closed L1253 let-value case!), Wasm 24, ANF 2, Lower 1. Spec coverage: 1696 refs, 0 mismatches, 45.4% (unchanged — jsspec in very long run since 09:00, 5.5hrs). Proof agent recovered from EXIT code 1 crashes, now actively working on forIn/forOf fix + captured var. wasmspec started new run at 14:30. KEY ARCHITECTURAL BLOCKERS IDENTIFIED: (1) CC L1113 (captured var) needs EnvObjCorr in CC_SimRel — wrote exact type signature in proof prompt, (2) Wasm break/continue/while/labeled UNPROVABLE due to hlabels_empty in LowerSimRel — wrote analysis in wasmspec prompt. Redirected wasmspec to return(some)/throw (provable NOW). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED). | | 2026-03-25T17:05 | 35 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 35: CC 9 (L1252 let-value some v still open — proof agent's worktree changes not merged yet), Wasm 22 (actual sorry, 24 incl comments), ANF 2, Lower 1. Spec coverage: 1696 refs, 0 mismatches, 45.4% (unchanged). jsspec finished (EXIT code 1 at 17:08). Proof agent still running (~2.5hrs). wasmspec still running (~2.5hrs). KEY FINDING: step_sim 1:1 is ARCHITECTURALLY WRONG — return(some), throw, let, seq, if need multi-step IR. Wrote concrete restructure to wasmspec prompt (change conclusion to IRSteps + add inner LowerCodeCorr to return_some). Also wrote EmitCodeCorr.load_i64/store_i64 (quick 2-sorry win). Proof prompt updated with L1252 priority. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED). | | 2026-03-25T18:05 | 35 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 35 (script): CC 8 (L1253 let-value CLOSED by proof!), Wasm 20 (i64 load/store CLOSED by wasmspec!), ANF 2, Lower 1 = 31 actual locations. 🎉 MILESTONE: 2006 refs, 0 mismatches, 55.6% coverage (24654/44380 lines) — jsspec +310 refs, +10.2% coverage since last run! Proof agent closed L1253 let-value sorry (net -1 CC). wasmspec closed i64 load/store + 2 more Emit cases (-4 Wasm since 17:05 count of 24). All agents just started new runs: proof 17:30, jsspec 17:30 (completed 18:13), wasmspec 18:15. ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS: CC L1113 (captured var) FUNDAMENTALLY needs stuttering simulation (2 Flat steps per 1 Core step) — wrote concrete ExprCorr + stuttering step_simulation to proof prompt. Redirected proof to objectLit/arrayLit first (1-1 stepping, tractable). wasmspec: all 5 EmitSimRel constructors+inversions exist, redirected to memoryGrow (quickest win). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED). |

| 2026-03-25T19:05 | 33 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 35→33 (-2): CC 8 (2 stubs + 6 real, ALL architecturally blocked by heap addr divergence), Wasm 20 (12 LowerSimRel + 5 EmitSimRel + 3 init), ANF 2, Lower 1. 🎉 MILESTONE: 2006 refs, 0 mismatches, 55.6% coverage (24654/44380 lines). CRITICAL ARCHITECTURAL FINDING: ALL 6 real CC sorries blocked by heap address divergence — Flat makeEnv allocates env objects to same heap as regular objects, so after any function def, sf.heap.nextAddr > sc.heap.nextAddr and objectLit/arrayLit allocate at different addresses. Fix requires separate env heap or address mapping in SimRel. Redirected proof agent to ANF (L106 step_star + L1365 left-spine flattening). wasmspec steady (-2, memoryGrow next). jsspec at target. Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED). | | 2026-03-25T20:05 | 35 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 35 (script count) / 31 actual locations: CC 8 (2 stubs + 6 real, ALL blocked), Wasm 20 (12 LowerSimRel + 5 EmitSimRel + 3 init), ANF 2, Lower 1. 🎉 SPEC COVERAGE EXPLOSION: 2450 refs, 0 mismatches, 93.6% coverage (41523/44380 lines) — jsspec +444 refs, +38% coverage since last run! No sorry progress this run. Proof agent running since 19:30 (ANF). wasmspec running since 19:15. jsspec running since 19:00. All 3 agents actively working. Wrote concrete memoryGrow proof to wasmspec prompt (quickest EmitSimRel win). Test262: 3/63 (UNCHANGED). | | 2026-03-25T21:05 | 33 | ~180 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 33 (script) / 29 actual: CC 8 (2 stubs + 6 real), Wasm 18 (12 LowerSimRel + 3 EmitSimRel + 3 init by sorry), ANF 2, Lower 1. 🎉🎉 SPEC COVERAGE 100%: 2800 refs, 0 mismatches, 44380/44380 lines (100.0%) — jsspec hit PERFECT coverage! ALL targets met. | | 2026-03-25T22:05 | 32 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 35→32 (-3): CC 3 (2 stubs + 1 staging HeapInj refactor exact sorry), Wasm 20, ANF 2, Lower 1. CC HeapInj REFACTORED: proof agent added HeapInj/EnvCorrInj/EnvAddrWF/HeapValuesWF/ExprAddrWF to CC_SimRel suffices (L915-937), but sorry'd entire case proof during staging. Currently staging aliases (HeapInj = HeapCorr, EnvCorrInj wraps EnvCorr). Phase 1 (real definitions) still in prompt. Spec coverage: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). wasmspec memoryGrow 4/5 subcases proved (only unreachable no-memory sorry at L9628 remains). Redirected proof to ANF L1499 (trivial chain), wasmspec to EmitSimRel call/callIndirect. | | 2026-03-25T23:30 | 32 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 32 (script) / 26 actual: CC 3 (2 stubs + 1 staging), Wasm 21 (12 LowerSimRel + 6 EmitSimRel + 3 init), ANF 1, Lower 1. 🎉 ANF L1499 CLOSED by proof agent (trivialChain infrastructure: wrapSeqCtx, step_wrapSeqCtx, trivialChain_consume_ctx). ANF now down to 1 sorry (L106 step_star). wasmspec structured call into OOB (proved) + underflow + success subcases (+1 net). Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). Redirected proof to CC L945 (restore step_sim — HeapInj/EnvCorrInj are aliases, so mechanical). Redirected wasmspec to br/brIf (most tractable EmitSimRel wins). | | 2026-03-26T00:05 | 32 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 32 (script) / 26 actual: CC 3 (L899 forIn stub, L900 forOf stub, L945 staging), Wasm 21 (12 LowerSimRel + 6 EmitSimRel + 3 init), ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). No sorry reduction since 23:30. Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). ANALYSIS: memoryGrow L9972 trivially closable (hmemory_nonempty contradicts none branch). br/brIf (L9715/L9718) ARCHITECTURALLY BLOCKED — need hlabel_name_resolve invariant connecting irFindLabel? to resolveBranch? indices. Redirected wasmspec to close L9972 (1-sorry quick win), then investigate br architecture. Proof agent focus: restore CC step_sim (L945) case-by-case since HeapInj is alias. | | 2026-03-26T02:05 | 57 | ~180 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 57 (script) — HIGH because grep counts individual case branches. Actual locations: CC 30 (2 stubs + 28 case-split branches at L989-1068 under L945 staging), Wasm 20 (12 LowerSimRel + 5 EmitSimRel + 3 init), ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). .this (L990-1040) PROVED — only non-sorry CC case. Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). Both proof and wasmspec agents STALLED (sorry velocity 0/run for 4+ runs). Wrote exact Lean code for break (L1063), continue (L1064), labeled (L1066) into proof prompt — each follows .this pattern exactly with trivial adaptations. These are the 3 quickest CC wins. Also wrote var subcase A (non-captured) instructions. wasmspec redirected to br/brIf with label correspondence helper. | | 2026-03-26T03:05 | 55 | ~180 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 57→55 (-2): CC 30→27 (proof closed break+continue+labeled, partial var), Wasm 21→20 (wasmspec closed memoryGrow no-memory). KEY FINDING: Emit.lean if_ label bug — wasmspec discovered emitInstrs for .if_ doesn't call pushLabel, so br indices inside if-bodies are off by 1. Fix is 1-line (pushLabel s "__if"). Wrote fix to wasmspec prompt + redirected to emit_br/brIf after fix. Proof agent prompt updated with return/throw/yield/await code (all follow break/continue pattern for base sub-cases). Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). | | 2026-03-26T04:05 | 55 | ~180 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 55 (script) / ~48 actual: CC 30 (2 stubs + 1 captured var + 17 compound + 4 stepping + 4 control flow + 2 stub-related), Wasm 23 (12 LowerSimRel + 5 EmitSimRel + 3 init + 2 emit_br + 1 other), ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). No sorry reduction since 03:05. Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). Emit.lean if_ label bug STILL UNFIXED (wasmspec hasn't applied 1-line pushLabel fix). Proof agent running since 03:30. Rewrote proof prompt with IH-based stepping sub-case architecture + concrete Lean code for Flat stepping helper lemmas + throw stepping proof skeleton. | | 2026-03-26T05:05 | 53 | ~180 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 55→53 (-2): CC 28 (2 stubs + 1 staging + 17 compound + 4 stepping + 4 control), Wasm 18-20 (12 LowerSimRel + 3 EmitSimRel + 3 init + emit_br helpers), ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). Proof: return/throw/yield/await VALUE sub-cases all proved last run (+6). Stepping sub-cases (4) remain = KEY BOTTLENECK. Wasmspec: br/brIf structurally closed but label resolution helpers sorry'd (blocked by Emit.lean if_ bug STILL UNFIXED). Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). Rewrote proof prompt with 8 concrete Flat/Core stepping helper lemmas + complete throw stepping proof using ih_depth. Wasmspec prompt unchanged (TASK 0 = fix Emit.lean if_ pushLabel). |

| 2026-03-26T07:05 | 48 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 53→48 (-5): CC 26 (2 stubs + 1 captured var + 1 staging L1308 + 17 compound + 5 structural), Wasm 20 (12 LowerSimRel + 5 EmitSimRel + 3 init), ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). Proof agent STRONG PROGRESS over last 4 runs: closed break, continue, labeled, var (non-captured both subcases), return (none + value + stepping), throw (value + stepping), yield (none + value + stepping), await (value + stepping). All 14 helper lemmas for unary/typeof/assign in place. Emit.lean if_ label bug STILL UNFIXED (6+ runs, wasmspec not applying 1-line pushLabel fix). Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). Proof prompt updated with verified unary/typeof/assign code (exact copy of return stepping pattern). | | 2026-03-26T08:05 | 45 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry DOWN 48→45 (-3): CC 23 (2 stubs + 1 staging + 17 compound + 3 remaining), Wasm 20, ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). Proof: closed unary+typeof+assign (value+stepping). Emit.lean if_ STILL UNFIXED (7+ runs). Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). | | 2026-03-26T09:05 | 45 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 45: CC 23 (2 stubs + 1 staging + 17 compound + 3 remaining), Wasm 20, ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). ROOT CAUSE FOUND: Emit.lean owned by proof user (640 perms) — wasmspec CANNOT write to it. Delegated if_ fix to proof agent (TASK 0). Proof prompt rewritten with COMPLETE deleteProp/getProp stepping code (copy-pasteable). Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). | | 2026-03-26T10:05 | 41 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅ (expected). Sorry DOWN 45→41 (-4): CC 21 (2 stubs + 1 staging + 1 captured var + 15 compound/stepping + 2 value sub-cases), Wasm 18 (12 LowerSimRel + 3 EmitSimRel call/callIndirect + 3 init), ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). 🎉 Emit.lean if_ fix APPLIED by proof agent (TASK 0 complete). deleteProp + getProp stepping PROVED (-2 CC). EmitSimRel br+brIf FULLY PROVED (no sorry!) — previously counted as 2-5 sorry. All single-sub-expression CC cases NOW DONE. Remaining CC cases are ALL compound (CCState threading needed). Redirected proof agent to value sub-cases of compound expressions (seq, if, let). Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). | | 2026-03-26T11:05 | 45 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry STEADY at 45 (script): CC 21 (2 stubs + 1 staging + 15 compound + 3 value sub-cases), Wasm 18 (12 LowerSimRel + 3 EmitSimRel call/callIndirect + 3 init), ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). All single-sub-expression CC cases DONE (unary/typeof/assign/deleteProp/getProp — both value+stepping). Proof agent prompt updated with EXACT Lean code for 3 helper lemmas (Flat_step?_seq_value, Flat_step?_let_value, Flat_step?_if_value) + complete seq/let value sub-case proofs. wasmspec blocked on permissions (Emit.lean fixed by proof agent). jsspec stable (100% coverage). Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). | | 2026-03-26T15:00 | 49 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅. Sorry 49 (script) / ~45 actual: CC 21 (2 stubs + 1 staging + 1 captured var + 4 CCState stepping + 13 compound/control), Wasm 22 (12 LowerSimRel + 4 EmitSimRel + 3+3 init), ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). No sorry reduction since 10:05 run (~5 hours). Proof agent ran multiple sessions (some EXIT code 1). wasmspec ran multiple sessions. Binary case CONFIRMED DONE (only lhs stepping sorry at L2209 = CCState issue). Proof prompt STALE — redirected to setProp decomposition (value + rhs-stepping sub-cases). wasmspec redirected to L6904 (return var — step_sim_return_var PROVED but not wired in). Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). | | 2026-03-26T16:05 | 49 | ~203 (est.) | Build PASS ✅ (expected). Sorry STEADY at 49: CC 25, Wasm 22, ANF 1 (L106), Lower 1 (L69). No sorry reduction for 6+ hours (stalled since 10:05). Proof agent running (building CC at 15:59). wasmspec NOT running. jsspec started 16:00. Rewrote BOTH proof+wasmspec prompts: proof → CCState helper lemma (4 sorries) + Core_step_heap_size_mono (4 sorries) + ANF decomposition; wasmspec → wire step_sim_return_var at L6904 (quick win) + litStr/litObject/litClosure. Spec: 100% (2800 refs, 0 mismatches). |

  • Test262 pass rate: 3/63 (fast mode), deterministic full sample reached 274/500 passes (2026-03-08)
  • Flagship parse rate: 96.30% (1976/2052)
  • E2E tests: 203 handcrafted JS programs (estimated pass rate ~96% when build works)

Infrastructure Issues

  • lake build fixed: Required GIT_CONFIG_GLOBAL=/tmp/supervisor_gitconfig with safe.directory = * (HOME=/opt/verifiedjs is not writable by supervisor). Also needed to create .lake/packages/aesop/.lake/build/ directory manually.
  • Script permissions: ./scripts/*.sh not executable for agents. Use bash scripts/*.sh or inline the logic.
  • File ownership: Lower.lean and other Wasm/*.lean files owned by proof with rw-r-----. Supervisor can read but not edit. Use GIT_CONFIG_GLOBAL env var for builds.
  • E2E wasm file permissions: tests/e2e/*.wasm owned by jsspec with rw-r-----. Supervisor e2e must write to /tmp instead. Agents that own tests/e2e/ can run run_e2e.sh directly.

End-to-End Proof Chain

Pass Theorem Statement OK? Proved? Blocker
Elaborate elaborate_correct YES PROVED —
ClosureConvert closureConvert_correct YES — trace preservation with NoForInForOf 21 sorry L903-904 forIn/forOf (2 UNPROVABLE stubs). L1410 captured var (1). L1545/1661 seq/let stepping (2). L1628 if (1). L1746-1748 binary/call/newObj (3). L1754/1813/1875 value heap sub-cases (3). L1807/1869 setProp/setIndex (2). L2017-2019 objectLit/arrayLit/functionDef (3). L2109-2112 tryCatch/while/forIn/forOf (4). seq/let VALUE sub-cases DONE. if case next (code in prompt).
ANFConvert anfConvert_correct YES — observable trace preservation 1 sorry L106 step_star (full theorem body). L1499 nested seq CLOSED ✅.
Optimize optimize_correct YES — ∀ b, ANF.Behaves (optimize p) b ↔ ANF.Behaves p b PROVED Identity pass — trivially correct
Lower lower_behavioral_correct YES — ∀ trace, ANF.Behaves → IR.IRBehaves 1 sorry Build FIXED. BLOCKED on wasmspec step_sim (:4956). SimRel needs code correspondence.
Emit emit_behavioral_correct YES — ∀ trace, IR.IRBehaves → Wasm.Behaves 1 sorry BLOCKED on wasmspec EmitSimRel.step_sim (:5058)
EndToEnd flat_to_wasm_correct YES — partial composition (Flat→Wasm) 1 sorry EndToEnd.lean:55. Composition of above; last to prove

Chain status: All 6 Behaves relations DEFINED. All theorem STATEMENTS correct. 2 passes FULLY PROVED (Elaborate, Optimize). Sorry count: 49 (script) / ~45 actual. CC step_sim: 24+ proved (lit, this, var-noncaptured, break, continue, labeled, return-none/value/stepping, throw-value/stepping, yield-none/value/stepping, await-value/stepping, unary-value/stepping, typeof-value/stepping, assign-value/stepping, deleteProp-value/stepping, getProp-value/stepping, getIndex-stepping, seq-value, let-value, if-value, binary-value/rhs-stepping), 21 sorry remaining (incl 2 stubs). All single-sub-expression + binary rhs-stepping DONE. setProp decomposition next. Wasm: stuttering infra (TrivialCodeCorr) covers return cases; litNull/litNum/litUndefined/litBool all proved. Flat/ SORRY-FREE. Core/ SORRY-FREE. ANF/Semantics SORRY-FREE. Build PASS ✅. Spec coverage: 2800 refs, 0 mismatches, 44380/44380 lines (100.0%). ALL TARGETS MET.

RESOLVED ABSTRACTIONS:

  • ✅ LowerCodeCorr constructors FIXED (wasmspec 01:15 — while_, throw, return_, break_, continue_ now specify actual instruction shapes)
  • ✅ ValueCorr DEFINED and added to LowerSimRel.henv (wasmspec 01:15)
  • ✅ EmitSimRel.hstack strengthened with Forall₂ correspondence (wasmspec 01:15)
  • ✅ 13 new EmitCodeCorr constructors + 7 inversion lemmas (wasmspec 01:15)

RESOLVED ABSTRACTIONS (this run):

  • ✅ Flat.initialState FIXED — includes console binding + heap (wasmspec 04:15)
  • ✅ toNumber returns NaN for undefined/string/object/closure (wasmspec 04:15)
  • ✅ bitNot does actual bitwise NOT (wasmspec 04:15)
  • ✅ valueToString defined, .throw/.return use it (wasmspec 04:15)
  • ✅ updateBindingList made public (wasmspec 04:15)
  • ✅ ANF break/continue → .silent (wasmspec 04:15)
  • ✅ EmitSimRel const i32/i64/f64 cases proved (wasmspec 04:15)

OPEN ABSTRACTIONS (updated 2026-03-26T15:00):

  1. CC setProp decomposition (next): 3 sub-cases: both-values (heap), value-stepping (follows binary rhs pattern), obj-stepping (CCState issue). Helpers + structure in proof prompt.
  2. CC compound stepping conversion sorries (4): if L1893, seq L1978, let L1695, binary L2209. All need CCState preservation: convertExpr output .fst depends on st.funcs.size/st.nextId when functionDef present. ARCHITECTURALLY BLOCKED.
  3. CC value sub-cases with heap (3 sorry): getProp L2217, getIndex L2276, setIndex L2338 — need heap reasoning under HeapInj.
  4. CC stubs (2 sorry): L903 forIn, L904 forOf — UNPROVABLE.
  5. CC captured var (1 sorry): L1508 — needs getEnv reasoning under EnvCorrInj.
  6. CC multi-sub (3 sorry): call L2210, newObj L2211, setIndex L2332.
  7. CC complex (3 sorry): objectLit L2480, arrayLit L2481, functionDef L2482.
  8. CC control flow (4 sorry): tryCatch L2572, while_ L2573, forIn L2574, forOf L2575.
  9. Wasm stuttering (4 sorry): return var L6904 (ALMOST DONE — step_sim_return_var proved, just needs wiring), litStr L6911, litObject L6912, litClosure L6913.
  10. Wasm LowerSimRel 1:1 (12 sorry): L6443-6520. ALL need 1:N stepping. ARCHITECTURALLY BLOCKED.
  11. Wasm EmitSimRel (4 sorry): L6904 (above) + call/callIndirect blocked by multi-frame.
  12. Wasm init (3+3 sorry): L10096-10110, L11102-11141.
  13. ANF (1 sorry): step_star L106.
  14. Lower (1 sorry): L69 init.

Critical path: (1) proof: Core_step_heap_size_mono → closes 4 ExprAddrWF_mono sorries. (2) proof: CCState preservation lemma → closes 4 more. (3) wasmspec: close litStr/litClosure + init sorries. (4) proof: ANF decomposition (5+ days stale).

Agent Health

Agent Status (2026-03-31T03:05) Notes
proof STUCK While loop matching lake serve (7h+ wasted). Timeout ~19:30.
jsspec ACTIVE Fresh session (03:00). Proved 2 CC sorries in last run. Working on CCStateAgree fix.
wasmspec STUCK While loop self-match (13h+ wasted). Timeout ~14:30.

Metrics (2026-03-31T03:05)

Metric Value
Sorry count 75 grep-c (17 CC + 58 ANF + 0 Lower)
Real sorries ~29 (13 CC + 16 ANF)
Build PASS (all modules clean)
Delta -2 from 01:05 (CC 19→17). jsspec proved convertExprList/PropList_firstNonValueExpr/Prop_some.
BLOCKER 1 ANF 42 aux lemma sorries fundamentally unprovable. Agent stuck, will delete on restart.
BLOCKER 2 CCStateAgree too strong for branching. Blocks 3 CC sorries. jsspec investigating fix.
BLOCKER 3 2 of 3 agents permanently stuck in while loops. Cannot kill (different users).