|
| 1 | +library: makie |
| 2 | +language: julia |
| 3 | +specification_id: rose-basic |
| 4 | +created: '2026-07-25T10:39:48Z' |
| 5 | +updated: '2026-07-25T10:59:44Z' |
| 6 | +generated_by: claude-sonnet |
| 7 | +workflow_run: 30154441735 |
| 8 | +issue: 1003 |
| 9 | +language_version: 1.11.9 |
| 10 | +library_version: 0.21.9 |
| 11 | +preview_url_light: https://storage.googleapis.com/anyplot-images/plots/rose-basic/julia/makie/plot-light.png |
| 12 | +preview_url_dark: https://storage.googleapis.com/anyplot-images/plots/rose-basic/julia/makie/plot-dark.png |
| 13 | +preview_html_light: null |
| 14 | +preview_html_dark: null |
| 15 | +quality_score: 91 |
| 16 | +review: |
| 17 | + strengths: |
| 18 | + - Alpha ramp keyed to value (0.55-1.0) plus outline strokes on the peak (Dec) and |
| 19 | + trough (Jul) wedges directly address the prior attempt's Design Excellence feedback, |
| 20 | + giving the chart a clear focal point without breaking the spec's 'consistent color |
| 21 | + scheme, single color with varying saturation' guidance |
| 22 | + - rticklabelsize bumped from 12 to 15, resolving the prior attempt's mobile-legibility |
| 23 | + weakness on radial tick labels |
| 24 | + - 'Correct rose/coxcomb geometry: equal-angle wedges via band! sampled over 40 arc |
| 25 | + points per wedge, radius (not area) proportional to value, true curved edges exploiting |
| 26 | + PolarAxis''s per-vertex transform' |
| 27 | + - 'Full theme-adaptive chrome — data colors (Imprint green #009E73 with alpha ramp) |
| 28 | + identical across both renders, only chrome (background, ink, grid) flips' |
| 29 | + - 'Thoughtful PolarAxis configuration: January at 12 o''clock, clockwise month ordering |
| 30 | + matching calendar convention' |
| 31 | + - Realistic, neutral monthly-rainfall data (33-95mm) with a plausible wet-winter/dry-summer |
| 32 | + temperate-coastal cycle |
| 33 | + - Clean KISS script, explicit font sizes throughout, deterministic via Random.seed!(42) |
| 34 | + weaknesses: |
| 35 | + - The radial tick labels for the 0mm and 20mm rings sit directly on top of the trough |
| 36 | + (Jul) wedge's colored fill rather than in clear whitespace, because that wedge |
| 37 | + itself extends past 20mm — this partially contradicts the code comment's stated |
| 38 | + intent to route labels through a gap. Text stays readable but contrast is reduced |
| 39 | + versus the plain background; consider nudging rtickangle further into true whitespace |
| 40 | + or skipping/repositioning the innermost 1-2 tick labels. |
| 41 | + - Still fundamentally a single-hue radial chart — the alpha ramp and peak/trough |
| 42 | + outlines add real hierarchy, but there is room for further polish (e.g., a subtle |
| 43 | + secondary visual cue) before this reaches top-tier Design Excellence. |
| 44 | + image_description: |- |
| 45 | + Light render (plot-light.png): |
| 46 | + Background: Warm off-white, consistent with #FAF8F1 — not pure white, not dark. |
| 47 | + Chrome: Title "Monthly Rainfall · rose-basic · julia · makie · anyplot.ai" in dark ink, comfortably sized and centered above the "Jan" label. 12 month labels (Jan-Dec) ring the outer edge clockwise from 12 o'clock, all clearly legible in dark gray/ink. Radial gridlines at 0/20/40/60/80/100 mm render as subtle light-gray circles. "mm"-suffixed radial tick labels are routed along the Jul/Aug angular gap; the 40/60/80/100 mm labels land cleanly in whitespace, but the 0 mm and 20 mm labels overlap the trough (Jul) wedge's own fill since that wedge extends past 20mm. |
| 48 | + Data: 12 equal-angle wedges filled in Imprint brand green (#009E73) with per-wedge alpha ramped from ~0.55 (driest month, Jul) to ~1.0 (wettest month, Dec) — radius proportional to rainfall value. The Dec (peak) and Jul (trough) wedges carry an additional dark outline stroke as an explicit callout, giving the chart a clear visual focal point on the wet/dry extremes. |
| 49 | + Legibility verdict: PASS (title, axis labels, and tick labels all readable against the light background; the 0mm/20mm tick labels sit on wedge fill rather than plain background, which is a minor contrast reduction but not a failure — text remains legible). |
| 50 | +
|
| 51 | + Dark render (plot-dark.png): |
| 52 | + Background: Warm near-black, consistent with #1A1A17 — not pure black, not light. |
| 53 | + Chrome: Same layout with chrome flipped — title and month labels in light ink/off-white, radial tick labels in light gray, gridlines in low-opacity light gray. No dark-on-dark failures; all chrome text reads clearly against the near-black surface. |
| 54 | + Data: Identical Imprint green (#009E73) wedges with the same alpha ramp and peak/trough outline treatment (now in a light/white stroke instead of dark) — confirms data colors are unchanged between themes, only chrome adapted. |
| 55 | + Legibility verdict: PASS (all text readable against the dark background; same minor 0mm/20mm tick-label-over-wedge-fill placement as the light render, but legible in both cases). |
| 56 | + criteria_checklist: |
| 57 | + visual_quality: |
| 58 | + score: 28 |
| 59 | + max: 30 |
| 60 | + items: |
| 61 | + - id: VQ-01 |
| 62 | + name: Text Legibility |
| 63 | + score: 7 |
| 64 | + max: 8 |
| 65 | + passed: true |
| 66 | + comment: rticklabelsize bumped to 15 (from 12), all text explicitly sized |
| 67 | + and readable in both themes; minor contrast dip where 0mm/20mm tick labels |
| 68 | + sit on wedge fill |
| 69 | + - id: VQ-02 |
| 70 | + name: No Overlap |
| 71 | + score: 5 |
| 72 | + max: 6 |
| 73 | + passed: true |
| 74 | + comment: 0mm and 20mm radial tick labels overlap the trough wedge's fill instead |
| 75 | + of clean whitespace; no text-on-text collisions |
| 76 | + - id: VQ-03 |
| 77 | + name: Element Visibility |
| 78 | + score: 6 |
| 79 | + max: 6 |
| 80 | + passed: true |
| 81 | + comment: 12 wedges appropriately sized/spaced; alpha ramp keeps every wedge |
| 82 | + distinguishable |
| 83 | + - id: VQ-04 |
| 84 | + name: Color Accessibility |
| 85 | + score: 2 |
| 86 | + max: 2 |
| 87 | + passed: true |
| 88 | + comment: High contrast, no red-green reliance, single-hue ramp is CVD-safe |
| 89 | + - id: VQ-05 |
| 90 | + name: Layout & Canvas |
| 91 | + score: 4 |
| 92 | + max: 4 |
| 93 | + passed: true |
| 94 | + comment: Rose fills the square 2400x2400 canvas with balanced margins, nothing |
| 95 | + clipped, canvas gate passed |
| 96 | + - id: VQ-06 |
| 97 | + name: Axis Labels & Title |
| 98 | + score: 2 |
| 99 | + max: 2 |
| 100 | + passed: true |
| 101 | + comment: Radial ticks carry explicit 'mm' units, angular axis self-describing |
| 102 | + via month labels |
| 103 | + - id: VQ-07 |
| 104 | + name: Palette Compliance |
| 105 | + score: 2 |
| 106 | + max: 2 |
| 107 | + passed: true |
| 108 | + comment: 'First series #009E73 identical across themes, backgrounds theme-correct |
| 109 | + (#FAF8F1 / #1A1A17)' |
| 110 | + design_excellence: |
| 111 | + score: 16 |
| 112 | + max: 20 |
| 113 | + items: |
| 114 | + - id: DE-01 |
| 115 | + name: Aesthetic Sophistication |
| 116 | + score: 6 |
| 117 | + max: 8 |
| 118 | + passed: true |
| 119 | + comment: Alpha ramp by value plus peak/trough outline callouts add real polish |
| 120 | + over the prior flat single-color fill |
| 121 | + - id: DE-02 |
| 122 | + name: Visual Refinement |
| 123 | + score: 5 |
| 124 | + max: 6 |
| 125 | + passed: true |
| 126 | + comment: Subtle low-opacity grid, single clean spine, generous whitespace |
| 127 | + - id: DE-03 |
| 128 | + name: Data Storytelling |
| 129 | + score: 5 |
| 130 | + max: 6 |
| 131 | + passed: true |
| 132 | + comment: Peak (Dec) and trough (Jul) wedges are now explicitly outlined, giving |
| 133 | + the seasonal story an immediate visual anchor |
| 134 | + spec_compliance: |
| 135 | + score: 15 |
| 136 | + max: 15 |
| 137 | + items: |
| 138 | + - id: SC-01 |
| 139 | + name: Plot Type |
| 140 | + score: 5 |
| 141 | + max: 5 |
| 142 | + passed: true |
| 143 | + comment: 'Correct rose/coxcomb chart: equal-angle wedges, radius-encoded values' |
| 144 | + - id: SC-02 |
| 145 | + name: Required Features |
| 146 | + score: 4 |
| 147 | + max: 4 |
| 148 | + passed: true |
| 149 | + comment: Radius (not area) proportional to value, natural circular ordering, |
| 150 | + consistent color w/ varying saturation, 12 o'clock start, radial gridlines |
| 151 | + - id: SC-03 |
| 152 | + name: Data Mapping |
| 153 | + score: 3 |
| 154 | + max: 3 |
| 155 | + passed: true |
| 156 | + comment: Category to angle, value to radius correct, all 12 months visible |
| 157 | + - id: SC-04 |
| 158 | + name: Title & Legend |
| 159 | + score: 3 |
| 160 | + max: 3 |
| 161 | + passed: true |
| 162 | + comment: Title format correct; single series, no legend needed |
| 163 | + data_quality: |
| 164 | + score: 14 |
| 165 | + max: 15 |
| 166 | + items: |
| 167 | + - id: DQ-01 |
| 168 | + name: Feature Coverage |
| 169 | + score: 5 |
| 170 | + max: 6 |
| 171 | + passed: true |
| 172 | + comment: Full seasonal cycle (33-95mm) with clear high/low, variation is fairly |
| 173 | + smooth |
| 174 | + - id: DQ-02 |
| 175 | + name: Realistic Context |
| 176 | + score: 5 |
| 177 | + max: 5 |
| 178 | + passed: true |
| 179 | + comment: Plausible, neutral temperate-coastal-city rainfall scenario |
| 180 | + - id: DQ-03 |
| 181 | + name: Appropriate Scale |
| 182 | + score: 4 |
| 183 | + max: 4 |
| 184 | + passed: true |
| 185 | + comment: Values and seasonality consistent with real temperate coastal climates |
| 186 | + code_quality: |
| 187 | + score: 10 |
| 188 | + max: 10 |
| 189 | + items: |
| 190 | + - id: CQ-01 |
| 191 | + name: KISS Structure |
| 192 | + score: 3 |
| 193 | + max: 3 |
| 194 | + passed: true |
| 195 | + comment: Imports -> data -> plot -> save, only a simple per-wedge loop |
| 196 | + - id: CQ-02 |
| 197 | + name: Reproducibility |
| 198 | + score: 2 |
| 199 | + max: 2 |
| 200 | + passed: true |
| 201 | + comment: Random.seed!(42) |
| 202 | + - id: CQ-03 |
| 203 | + name: Clean Imports |
| 204 | + score: 2 |
| 205 | + max: 2 |
| 206 | + passed: true |
| 207 | + comment: CairoMakie, Colors, Random all used |
| 208 | + - id: CQ-04 |
| 209 | + name: Code Elegance |
| 210 | + score: 2 |
| 211 | + max: 2 |
| 212 | + passed: true |
| 213 | + comment: Appropriately complex, comments justify band! over poly! and the |
| 214 | + alpha/outline choices |
| 215 | + - id: CQ-05 |
| 216 | + name: Output & API |
| 217 | + score: 1 |
| 218 | + max: 1 |
| 219 | + passed: true |
| 220 | + comment: Saves plot-$(THEME).png via current API |
| 221 | + library_mastery: |
| 222 | + score: 8 |
| 223 | + max: 10 |
| 224 | + items: |
| 225 | + - id: LM-01 |
| 226 | + name: Idiomatic Usage |
| 227 | + score: 4 |
| 228 | + max: 5 |
| 229 | + passed: true |
| 230 | + comment: PolarAxis with correct theta_0/direction/rtick configuration |
| 231 | + - id: LM-02 |
| 232 | + name: Distinctive Features |
| 233 | + score: 4 |
| 234 | + max: 5 |
| 235 | + passed: true |
| 236 | + comment: band! sampled over 40 points per wedge exploits PolarAxis's per-vertex |
| 237 | + transform for true curved arcs — a Makie-specific technique |
| 238 | + verdict: APPROVED |
| 239 | +impl_tags: |
| 240 | + dependencies: [] |
| 241 | + techniques: |
| 242 | + - polar-projection |
| 243 | + - manual-ticks |
| 244 | + patterns: |
| 245 | + - data-generation |
| 246 | + - iteration-over-groups |
| 247 | + dataprep: [] |
| 248 | + styling: |
| 249 | + - alpha-blending |
| 250 | + - edge-highlighting |
| 251 | + - grid-styling |
0 commit comments