Skip to content

gameplay-improvements.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
130 lines (83 loc) · 6.78 KB

gameplay-improvements.md

File metadata and controls

130 lines (83 loc) · 6.78 KB
Raw

Gameplay Improvements (Playing Standpoint)

Suggestions to improve how games feel to play: clarity, fairness, discoverability, and engagement. Based on a pass through the fun commands and their UIs.

Table of Contents

Blackjack

Current: Hit, Stand, Extend time. Dealer stands on 17. Cooldown 5s, game timeout 1h.

  • Double down missing – Comment in code mentions "hit/stand/double" but only Hit and Stand exist. Adding a Double button (one extra card, then dealer plays) would match real blackjack and add meaningful choice.
  • No Split – Splitting pairs is optional but would deepen strategy; lower priority than Double.
  • Timeout outcome – On timeout the message shows "Dealer wins" + "Timed out". Consider: "You didn't play in time; round forfeited." so it's clear it wasn't a normal loss.
  • Blackjack payout – Message says "You win 3:2!" but there's no currency/bet; consider "Blackjack! (3:2 payout)" or keep as-is for flavor.

Wordle

Current: Daily word, 6 guesses, modal input, 🟩🟨⬛ feedback, letter bank, share line, resume.

  • Invalid words count as guesses – The modal only checks length (5) and [a-z]. Words like AAAAA or XYZAB are accepted and consume a guess. Validate against the word list (e.g. WORDS in gameLogic.ts or a separate "valid guesses" list) and reply ephemerally: "Not in word list. Try another 5-letter word." without using a guess.
  • Discoverability of stats – First-time players may not know /fun wordle stats exists. Optional: add a small line under the grid when the game ends: "See your stats: /fun wordle stats".
  • Resume message – "Continuing your game..." is good; consider adding "X guesses so far" when resuming so they know where they left off.

Slots

Current: One spin per command, paytable/leaderboard/stats via flags, jackpot tracking.

  • Paytable visibility – Players only see paytable if they use /fun slots paytable:True. Consider showing a short paytable in the footer of the spin embed (e.g. "3-of-kind: 5–100× | Two match: 2×") or a "View paytable" hint so they don't need to discover the option.
  • "2x" meaning – Paytable says "Two matching symbols: 2x". Since there's no bet, "2×" is a multiplier on… what? Consider "Two matching: 2× (small win)" so it's clear it's a small win tier, not a bet multiplier.
  • Biggest win in stats – Stats show "Biggest Win: X" when present; good. No change needed.

Hangman

Current: Letter dropdowns (A–M, N–Z), difficulty, 6 wrong guesses, solve time on win.

  • Wrong letters – "Wrong: A, B (2/6)" is clear. Consider always showing the fraction even when wrong list is empty: "Wrong: (0/6)" so lives remaining are obvious at a glance.
  • Difficulty in message – "Difficulty: Easy" is shown; good. No change needed.

Rock–Paper–Scissors

Current: Solo vs bot (one shot), challenge with opponent (both pick; 24h timeout).

  • Solo – Single round, then done. Optional: add a "Play again" button that re-runs a round (same command, no new flow) to reduce typing /fun rps choice:rock again.
  • Challenge – Both players see the same buttons; decline and extend are clear. Head-to-head stats are a nice touch. No major changes.

Trivia

Current: One question per /fun trivia, 30s to answer, category/difficulty, points and streaks.

  • One question per command – To play again you run /fun trivia again. Optional: after answering (correct or wrong), show a "Next question" button that fetches another question and updates the message (same collector or new), so players can binge without re-typing the command.
  • Timeout – "Time's up! The answer was: X" and buttons disabled is clear. Good.

Connect 4 (PvP)

Current: 7 columns, 🔴/🟡, turn line, 30 min per move, extend (starter only).

  • Turn line – "Turn: 🔴 @user1" is clear. Good.
  • Column labels – "1️⃣2️⃣3️⃣4️⃣5️⃣6️⃣7️⃣" under the board matches buttons 1–7. Good.
  • Full column – Buttons are disabled when board[0][col] !== 0. Consider adding a small note when the last column fills: "Game is a draw" if you support draw detection (or already do).

Tic Tac Toe

Current: Vs bot (❌ vs ⭕) and vs player; 3×3 grid, extend time.

  • Vs bot – "Your turn! Click a square." is clear. Bot move is immediate after player. Good.
  • Vs player – Same turn-indication pattern as Connect 4 would help (e.g. "Turn: ❌ @user1").

Darts

Current: Solo = one throw (3 darts), challenge = both throw once, higher score wins.

  • Solo – Single throw of 3 darts, then done. Optional: "Throw again" button for another round without re-typing the command.
  • Challenge – Clear who threw what; H2H stats are good. No change needed.
  • Scoring – Display of hits and total score is clear. Optional: brief rules in help (e.g. "3 darts per throw; highest score wins in PvP").

Cross-cutting

  • Cooldowns – Messages like "Wait X seconds before playing again" are clear. Consider linking to the command: "Use /fun slots again in Xs."
  • Extend time – Games that have "Extend time" explain it well (e.g. "+30 min for this move"). Good.
  • Ephemeral vs public – Most games post in-channel so others can watch; Wordle has a channel tease. Consistent and good.
  • Help – /help topic:games (or similar) could list each game with one line and a tip (e.g. "Wordle: invalid words don't count if you add validation").

Priority summary

Priority Item
High Wordle: validate guess against word list so invalid words don't use a guess.
Medium Blackjack: add Double button (and clarify timeout message).
Medium Slots: surface paytable in spin embed or footer so players don’t need to discover the flag.
Low Trivia: "Next question" button after each answer.
Low RPS solo / Darts solo: "Play again" or "Throw again" button.
Low Hangman: show "Wrong: (0/6)" when no wrong letters yet.

If you want, the next step can be implementing the Wordle word validation and/or the Blackjack Double button.