The engine opened this item itself — you didn't create it.
What this is. Every hard check must be proven to bite — a standing, CI-enforced negative-fixture meta-check that runs each in-scope hard check-logic unit against a committed negative fixture (a seeded bad input) and asserts the expected hard finding. It is the up-front enforcing correlate to the weak after-the-fact "possibly inert" telemetry flag, and it closes the false-green-gate / checker-of-checkers risk: a hard check that is a green no-op reads to the operator as "verified" when nothing was actually checked.
- Design of record: engine-planning decision log D-256 (authorize), resolved across D-257 (validation: the law + execution model), D-258 (check: the by-presence fixture grammar), D-259 (validators-core: the rule instance), D-260 (core: the dispatcher entry point + the core-kind fixtures).
- Scope = logic-unit: each kind callable (the five closed core kinds + any module-added kind) carries at least one negative fixture; each
custom/script instance carries its own; a data rule of a proven kind inherits the kind's proof.
- Honest ceiling: it proves a witnessed negative trips the check today — never completeness against every input or stability under drift. The only carve-out is a unit with no statically-decidable CI failure path, which resolves to a disclosed not-applicable.
What happens next. Build it — no new check kind; it rides custom/script:
- validators-core — the meta-check as a
custom/script rule (the sibling of the first-run reference-closure check): self-covering (carries its own negative fixture; the guard must not be falsifiable by what it judges), failing closed on a present in-scope unit whose fixture is absent (rosters: kind callables from the validator's kind registry, custom/script instances from the check-rule directory listing); assert the finding by set-membership (id/severity present), never order/count.
- core — a dispatcher entry point that runs one rule (or kind) against a caller-substituted target (extends the existing direct
coherence-kind invocation; the target-substitution is the new affordance), and ship each of the five closed kinds' negative fixtures co-located with their callables.
- fixtures namespace — a reserved, glob-excluded, coverage-exempt location under
.engine/ (a Tier-2 leaf per the repository-topology two-tier model; non-surface like .engine/tools/ / .engine/boot/), so a committed bad input neither reds the real suite nor reads as an orphan surface.
custom/script contract — pin the fail-closed modes (missing script, nonzero exit, unreadable JSON output -> each a hard finding on finding.v1); the fixtures exercise each mode.
- Backfill — author negative fixtures for the existing in-scope hard-check set (complete-final-state, not new-checks-only): the five closed core kinds, the reference-closure check (decidable legs only; its computed-path leg and no-op-after-retire state are disclosed not-applicable), PR-body completeness, the presence checks.
- Operator-facing — validation's "What the operator is told": a passing check means the engine proved that gate catches a deliberately broken example — proof the gate works, not proof the change is correct (keep maintainer vocabulary out of operator strings).
The engine opened this item itself — you didn't create it.
What this is. Every hard check must be proven to bite — a standing, CI-enforced negative-fixture meta-check that runs each in-scope hard check-logic unit against a committed negative fixture (a seeded bad input) and asserts the expected
hardfinding. It is the up-front enforcing correlate to the weak after-the-fact "possibly inert" telemetry flag, and it closes the false-green-gate / checker-of-checkers risk: a hard check that is a green no-op reads to the operator as "verified" when nothing was actually checked.custom/scriptinstance carries its own; a data rule of a proven kind inherits the kind's proof.What happens next. Build it — no new check kind; it rides
custom/script:custom/scriptrule (the sibling of the first-run reference-closure check): self-covering (carries its own negative fixture; the guard must not be falsifiable by what it judges), failing closed on a present in-scope unit whose fixture is absent (rosters: kind callables from the validator's kind registry,custom/scriptinstances from the check-rule directory listing); assert the finding by set-membership (id/severity present), never order/count.coherence-kind invocation; the target-substitution is the new affordance), and ship each of the five closed kinds' negative fixtures co-located with their callables..engine/(a Tier-2 leaf per the repository-topology two-tier model; non-surface like.engine/tools//.engine/boot/), so a committed bad input neither reds the real suite nor reads as an orphan surface.custom/scriptcontract — pin the fail-closed modes (missing script, nonzero exit, unreadable JSON output -> each ahardfinding onfinding.v1); the fixtures exercise each mode.