diff --git a/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/ConditionallyNotifiable.kt b/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/ConditionallyNotifiable.kt
new file mode 100644
index 000000000..6c80f79a3
--- /dev/null
+++ b/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/ConditionallyNotifiable.kt
@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+package com.getcode.utils
+
+/**
+ * Interface for errors where notifiability depends on runtime state.
+ * [ErrorUtils] checks [isNotifiable] to decide whether to report to Bugsnag.
+ */
+interface ConditionallyNotifiable {
+    val isNotifiable: Boolean
+}
diff --git a/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/ErrorUtils.kt b/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/ErrorUtils.kt
index 86bb2c0a8..11e4af35f 100644
--- a/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/ErrorUtils.kt
+++ b/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/ErrorUtils.kt
@@ -64,9 +64,11 @@ object ErrorUtils {
             ignoredErrors.none { it.isInstance(throwable) } &&
             ignoredErrors.none { it.isInstance(throwableCause) }
         ) {
-            val isNotifiable = throwable is NotifiableError
-                || throwableCause is NotifiableError
-                || throwableCause !is CodeServerError
+            val isNotifiable = when {
+                throwable is ConditionallyNotifiable -> throwable.isNotifiable
+                throwableCause is ConditionallyNotifiable -> throwableCause.isNotifiable
+                else -> throwableCause !is CodeServerError
+            }
 
             reporters.forEach { it.report(throwable, throwableCause, isNotifiable) }
         }
diff --git a/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/NotifiableError.kt b/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/NotifiableError.kt
index 577a7c7ff..db9e74538 100644
--- a/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/NotifiableError.kt
+++ b/libs/logging/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/utils/NotifiableError.kt
@@ -4,4 +4,6 @@ package com.getcode.utils
  * Marker interface for errors representing unexpected failures (not user-caused).
  * Errors implementing this are tagged in Bugsnag with metadata that triggers Slack notifications.
  */
-interface NotifiableError
+interface NotifiableError : ConditionallyNotifiable {
+    override val isNotifiable: Boolean get() = true
+}
diff --git a/services/opencode/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/opencode/model/core/errors/Errors.kt b/services/opencode/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/opencode/model/core/errors/Errors.kt
index 9aca5a08a..c355e312b 100644
--- a/services/opencode/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/opencode/model/core/errors/Errors.kt
+++ b/services/opencode/src/main/kotlin/com/getcode/opencode/model/core/errors/Errors.kt
@@ -9,6 +9,7 @@ import com.getcode.opencode.model.core.errors.SubmitIntentError.Signature
 import com.getcode.opencode.model.core.errors.SubmitIntentError.StaleState
 import com.getcode.opencode.model.core.errors.SubmitIntentError.Unrecognized
 import com.getcode.utils.CodeServerError
+import com.getcode.utils.ConditionallyNotifiable
 import com.getcode.utils.NotifiableError
 
 sealed class CodeAccountCheckError(
@@ -122,11 +123,27 @@ sealed class SubmitIntentError(
             if (details.isNotEmpty()) append(": ${details.joinToString()}")
         }), NotifiableError
     data class StaleState(private val reasons: List<String>) :
-        SubmitIntentError(message = reasons.joinToString()), NotifiableError {
+        SubmitIntentError(message = reasons.joinToString()), ConditionallyNotifiable {
         val isRaceCondition: Boolean
             get() = reasons.any { it.startsWith("race detected:") }
         val isGiftCardAlreadyClaimed: Boolean
             get() = reasons.any { it.contains("gift card balance has already been claimed") }
+        val isGiftCardExpired: Boolean
+            get() = reasons.any { it.contains("gift card is expired") }
+        val isPoolAlreadyDistributed: Boolean
+            get() = reasons.any { it.contains("pool balance has already been distributed") }
+        val isIntentAlreadyExists: Boolean
+            get() = reasons.any { it.contains("intent already exists") }
+
+        val isExpected: Boolean
+            get() = isRaceCondition
+                || isGiftCardAlreadyClaimed
+                || isGiftCardExpired
+                || isPoolAlreadyDistributed
+                || isIntentAlreadyExists
+
+        override val isNotifiable: Boolean
+            get() = !isExpected
     }
 
     data class Denied(private val reasons: List<String>) :