Grading Rubric

Project Scoring Rubric

Here is our rubric for scoring Python 2025 projects!

Do note that for every day late in submission of projects, 1 point will be deducted from the team's total score. The final submission date without penalties is on 20250620 at 23:59 hrs.

	Poor (1)	Average (2)	Good (3)
Hosting	Program not hosted anywhere.	Program not hosted on an accessible git server. Git commands unavailable for downloading project.	Project properly hosted on a publicly accessible git server. git clone <url> function pulls in a complete project.
README.md	No README.md found, README.md is unmodified from upstream, or contents of README.md file are irrelevant.	A rudimentary README.md file is included but fails to adequately cover how ComfyUI is modified and used.	A README.md file is included with the project, fully describing how ComfyUI was used and modified for generating the images and video.
Wiki	Wiki documentation not done.	Wiki documentation is rudimentary, and does not provide more guidance than that already found in the README.md file.	Wiki properly used to document additional background and usage of project with examples, notes on limitations, and other pieces of information.
Functionality	ComfyUI fork doesn't work.	ComfyUI fork works but is unmodified.	ComfyUI was modified and still works.
In-line Comments	None or irrelevant comments.	Inconsistent comments, but what is there is useful.	Clear comments that explain what the learner was trying to achieve for each modification.
Improvements	No improvements based upon the upstream project was made.	At least one area of improvement was made to the project based on the upstream project it is based on.	Project was improved upon above and beyond what was expected of the learner.
Elements	Included none of the following elements: Custom model selection Random function Variables Integers Input/Output Print While loops If/Else statements	Included some of the following elements: Custom model selection Random function Variables Integers Input/Output Print While loops If/Else statements	Included most of the following elements: Custom model selection Random function Variables Integers Input/Output Print While loops If/Else statements
Presentation	No clear explanation provided.	Presentation is mostly understandable, but missing crucial details that require further clarification.	Provides a clear and thorough explanation of the project such that no additional questions are required.
Video Score	Video is irrelevant due to not using ComfyUI or plagiarized without attribution from other sources.	10 second or shorter video that uses images generated from ComfyUI but is lacking sound, storytelling, or other means that makes a compelling video beyond a tech showcase.	10 second or less video using ComfyUI generated images that is coherent and entertaining.
ComfyUI Workflow	Unchanged default workflow.	Modifications to default workflow.	Exceptional customization to default ComfyUI workflow for the purposes of the participant's project.

Additional scoring rubric for group efforts:

	Poor (1)	Average (2)	Good (3)
Bug Reports	No bug reporting ever used to address issues.	Bug reports filed, but lack actionable details.	Bug reports used to highlight important issues with proper debugging information for developers to attempt to duplicate.
Pull Requests	No usage of pull request feature.	Usage of pull request feature not done appropriately to address issues.	Proper use of pull request feature that allows improvements to the project efficiently.
Merge	No merging of branches or pull requests.	Improper merging of branches or pull requests resulting in faulty code.	Proper usage of merging of branches and pull requests that improves the main project branch without causing unexpected faults.