fix(troubleshoot): remove relative-path confounder from python-pipe scenario#1813
fix(troubleshoot): remove relative-path confounder from python-pipe scenario#1813dmorosanu wants to merge 1 commit into
Conversation
|
Claude finished @dmorosanu's task in 1m 34s —— View job PR Review: fix(troubleshoot): remove relative-path confounder from python-pipe scenario
SummaryRemoves a diagnostic confounder from the Change-by-Change Review1.
|
| Area | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Frontmatter | N/A | No SKILL.md or frontmatter changes |
| E2E Tests | OK | Scenario fixture updated; task.yaml and success criteria unchanged and correct |
| Skill Body | N/A | No skill body changes |
| References & Assets | OK | RESOLUTION.md already consistent with the fix |
| Repo Hygiene | OK | No secrets, no personal paths, change scoped to single file |
Issues for Manual Review
None found.
Conclusion
Clean, well-scoped fix. The two-line change removes a legitimate diagnostic confounder without touching the scenario's ground truth or evaluation criteria. The PR description's claim of 5/5 coder-eval passes is consistent with the change. Approve.
The
python-pipe-broken-missing-modulescenario was ambiguous: itsMain.xamlpassed a relative csv path (invoices\inv-2026-05.csv) with a blankWorkingFoldertopd.read_csv. That produces the same swallowed "Pipe is broken" signature as the intended missing-pandas cause, so aFileNotFoundError-from-relative-path diagnosis was equally supported by the evidence — making the scenario flaky and its RESOLUTION unreachable by reasoning.Removes the confounder: absolute csv path +
WorkingFolder="C:\Robot\Data", leaving the third-partyimport pandasas the only plausible hidden cause. Consistent with RESOLUTION.md, which already states this is "not a WorkingFolder / relative-path issue."Scenario-only change (one
Main.xaml, 2 lines); no playbook, fixture-log, or RESOLUTION edits. Validated locally via coder-eval: 5/5 runs now reach the correct missing-pandas diagnosis (skill_triggered 1.0; llm_judge graded by hand as the local judge transport is unconfigured).