New concepts #1522
There are no files selected for viewing
| Original file line number | Diff line number | Diff line change |
|---|---|---|
|
|
@@ -4130,4 +4130,22 @@ ID GLOSS SEMANTICFIELD DEFINITION ONTOLOGICAL_CATEGORY REPLACEMENT_ID | |
| 4145 WRENCH Basic actions and technology A hand tool with a shaped jaw or adjustable head used for gripping, turning, or tightening nuts, bolts, and other fasteners. Person/Thing | ||
| 4146 SLINGSHOT Warfare and hunting A handheld weapon consisting of a forked frame with elastic bands used to propel small projectiles, such as stones or pellets, by tension and release. Person/Thing | ||
| 4147 CEDAR Agriculture and vegetation A large evergreen coniferous tree of the genus Cedrus or related genera, valued for its aromatic, durable wood and needle-like leaves. Person/Thing | ||
| 4148 TENSE Emotions and values Characterized by mental or muscular strain, stress, or heightened alertness; can describe emotions, physical states, or situations. Property | ||
| 4149 APARTMENT The house A set of rooms forming a self-contained housing unit within a larger building, used as a residence. Person/Thing | ||
| 4150 BAGPIPE Basic actions and technology A musical instrument consisting of a bag that supplies air to one or more pipes, producing continuous tones when played. Person/Thing | ||
| 4151 BAT (BASEBALL) Modern world A solid, typically wooden or metal club used by a player to hit the ball in the sport of baseball. Person/Thing | ||
| 4152 BEETROOT Agriculture and vegetation A cultivated root vegetable of the variety Beta vulgaris with a round, typically dark red bulbous root, used as food. Person/Thing | ||
| 4153 CABIN The house A small, simple, and often roughly built shelter, typically made of wood and located in a remote or rural area. Person/Thing | ||
| 4154 CATHEDRAL Religion and belief A large and principal church that serves as the official seat of a bishop within a Christian diocese. Person/Thing | ||
| 4155 CHAPEL Religion and belief A small place of Christian worship, typically serving a private community or institution Person/Thing | ||
|
Collaborator
There was a problem hiding this comment. Missing the point after the description. |
||
| 4156 CLAMS Animals Edible marine bivalve mollusks with two hinged shells, commonly found buried in sand or mud. Person/Thing | ||
| 4157 CLARINET Basic actions and technology A woodwind musical instrument with a single reed mouthpiece, a cylindrical tube, and finger holes or keys used to produce sound. Person/Thing | ||
| 4158 CORK Agriculture and vegetation A lightweight, porous plant tissue obtained from the bark of cork oak trees, commonly used as a sealing material for bottles and insulation. Person/Thing | ||
| 4159 CORKSCREW Basic actions and technology A hand tool consisting of a spiraled metal screw attached to a handle, used for inserting into and removing corks from bottles. Person/Thing | ||
| 4160 GOLDFISH Animals A small freshwater fish of the carp family, commonly kept as an ornamental pet in aquariums and ponds. Person/Thing | ||
| 4161 HOSE Basic actions and technology A flexible tube used to convey liquids or gases, typically water, from one place to another. Person/Thing | ||
| 4162 SKYSCRAPER Modern world A very tall, continuously habitable building with many floors, designed for residential, commercial, or mixed use in urban areas. Person/Thing | ||
| 4163 SLIPPER Clothing and grooming A soft, lightweight indoor shoe typically worn for comfort and warmth at home. Person/Thing | ||
| 4164 TUNA Animals A large marine fish of the genus Thunnus, known for its streamlined body and importance as a commercial food species. Person/Thing | ||
| 4165 YACHT Modern world A recreational boat or vessel, typically medium to large in size, used for leisure cruising or racing on water. Person/Thing | ||
| 4166 FOOTBALL Modern world A sport played by two teams in which players move a ball toward a goal to score points, mainly by kicking or carrying it OR the ball used in that sport. Person/Thing | ||
|
Collaborator
There was a problem hiding this comment. Are we fine with this meaning both the sport and the ball itself? I fear that this could create problems in the long run.
Collaborator
There was a problem hiding this comment.
We should. But we don't right now, correct?
Collaborator
There was a problem hiding this comment. I just found this discussion. @LinguList this involves your proposal to have a single concept that refers to both object and game. I have to say, I am not convinced. Was there some general agreement to such cases before?
Collaborator
There was a problem hiding this comment. @FredericBlum Thanks for the review! @MiraAhmedovic Could you ping @LinguList on Mattermost regarding this discussion? We also wondered how we should handle this, but we couldn’t find a previous concept set to use as a guide.
Collaborator
Author
There was a problem hiding this comment. I wasn't aware of that discussion, thank you for bringing it up! Since we don't have a lot of sports in Concepticon, there was no case to compare this mapping to. There are 6 unmapped lists for "basketball" but we run into the same issue, where it is only clear for one of those lists that it's the ball and for one that it is the game and the other four remain ambiguous. I think having two separate concepts and then one shared one for the ambiguous cases seems reasonable overall. The only concern I have is that this could scale quite quickly, since we would need to apply the same split to other polysemous items, which would increase overall granularity.
Contributor
There was a problem hiding this comment. Is there a problem with this suggestion, given that we discussed the ambiguity?
Contributor
There was a problem hiding this comment. We have similar situations in "burn", where we cannot determine often, if it is something that burns or somebody burning something, or with MUROID (MOUSE OR RAT).
Collaborator
Author
There was a problem hiding this comment. I’ll split them. Depending on the outcome of the American vs. European football question, we should probably also discuss how "soccer" should be mapped (3 lists).
Collaborator
There was a problem hiding this comment. Just to add my two cents: In the datasets that I have previously added, FOOTBALL always links to the ball, not the sport. @MiraAhmedovic
Collaborator
There was a problem hiding this comment. @MiraAhmedovic I have now added comments at the specific datasets where I am sure that they are either listing the ball vs. game and then also american football ball vs. european football ball. |
||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
How do we disentangle this from TIGHT? Should we separate the physical from the emotional?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
That was the idea here, yes. Should it be made more concrete?