Skip to content

fix(R5): rewrite CITATION.cff abstract to drop unverifiable claims#42

Merged
gHashTag merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
fix/zenodo-repo-honest-deepsweep
May 12, 2026
Merged

fix(R5): rewrite CITATION.cff abstract to drop unverifiable claims#42
gHashTag merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
fix/zenodo-repo-honest-deepsweep

Conversation

@gHashTag
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

🔴 R5-HONEST · Phase 3 of L-DOI-HONEST sweep

Companion to PR #739 (trios), PR #137 (trainer), and ZENODO-REHAB report.

Context

Phase 2 (Zenodo metadata rehab, 2026-05-12) made all canonical Trinity Zenodo records R5-honest: "software description stub, not a peer-reviewed paper", linked to gHashTag/t27/coq witness (48 statements, 35 Proven, 0 Admitted).

Phase 3 (this PR) fixes the matching repo-side overclaims that survived the previous sweep — found via deep-grep across gHashTag/{trios,trinity,trinity-fpga,trios-trainer-igla} (279 files touched 10.5281/zenodo.*, 7 carried R5 violations).

Witness

  • See companion PRs in sibling repos under branch fix/zenodo-repo-honest-deepsweep.
  • Coq audit reproduction: grep -rE '^\s*(Theorem|Lemma|Qed|Admitted)\s+' coq --include='*.v' in gHashTag/t27.

Anchor

phi^2 + phi^-2 = 3 (algebraic identity, not an empirical claim).

Phase 3 of L-DOI-HONEST sweep. Mirrors gHashTag/trinity#fix/zenodo-repo-honest-deepsweep.

The previous abstract claimed 'Full FAIR compliance with statistical
rigor' which is not auditable from the repo content. The new abstract
is honest: research software stack, software description stubs, Coq
witness with audited counts (48 statements / 35 Proven / 0 Admitted
on 2026-05-12) linked from gHashTag/t27/coq.

Anchor: phi^2 + phi^-2 = 3 (algebraic identity).
…ustified 'statistical rigor' keyword

PASS-2 of L-DOI-HONEST. Same fix as trinity#591 PASS-2: Phase-3 quoted
48 statements / 35 Proven / 0 Admitted (a SUBSET, only trios/docs/phd/
theorems/Kernel/*). The full audited gHashTag/t27 corpus on 2026-05-12 is:
28 .v files | 218 statements | 162 Qed | 32 Admitted | 11 Abort.

Also drops the "statistical rigor" keyword (not a property of this
software package — it is a methodology in the companion PhD monograph).

Anchor: phi^2 + phi^-2 = 3 (algebraic identity).

Co-authored-by: Trinity Queen Hive <queen-hive@trinity.local>
@gHashTag
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

🌀 PASS-2 push — this PR now contains an additional commit closing R5 violations the original Phase-3 sweep missed.

What's new in PASS-2:

  • The Phase-3 Coq counts (48 statements / 35 Proven / 0 Admitted) were a SUBSET of trios/docs/phd/theorems/Kernel/* + /Theorems/*. The authoritative gHashTag/t27 corpus (./coq + ./proofs) on 2026-05-12 is 28 .v files, 218 statements, 162 Qed, 32 Admitted, 11 Abort. Every place that quoted the old subset is now updated.
  • Additional R5 sweep across *.rs, *.cff, artifact/CLAIMS.md, tools/acm_ae_check/src/lib.rs, trinity-clara/proofs/README.md, docs/research/coq-invariants-strategy.md.
  • docs/golden-sunflowers/app-b-golden-ledger-297-qed-canonical-sha-1.md describes a t27/proofs/canonical/_Manifest.json infrastructure that does NOT exist — prepended [SUPERSEDED] banner with the audited counts.
  • CITATION.cff (trinity + trinity-fpga): unjustified "statistical rigor" keyword dropped; abstract refined to say per-experiment statistical results are not asserted by the cite-card.

📜 Full NASA mission report: ZENODO-REPO-AUDIT-PASS-2-2026-05-12-T23:50

φ² + φ⁻² = 3 · R5-HONEST · TRINITY

…3 (mirror)

PASS-3 anomalies fixed in trinity-fpga (25 files, mirror of trinity):
- docs/research/.zenodo.B00{1..7,PARENT}_v{8,9}.0.json (16 files): same hallucinated-DOI cleanup + 5 self-DOI corrections (B003-B007)
- .trinity/patent/status.json: D-series 19020211/13/15/17 -> 19020270/75/80/82 + _audit field
- src/tri/tri_zenodo.zig:1547: hardcoded JSON literal patched
- docs/lab/papers/patent-strategy/full-analysis.md + 7 zenodo-descriptions/*.html: D-series sweep

R5 verification: 0 hallucinated/superseded DOI references remain in trinity-fpga.

Anchor: phi^2 + phi^-2 = 3
Issue: gHashTag/trios#264
@gHashTag
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

🔥 PASS-3 update — three new anomaly classes purged

This PR was expanded with PASS-3 fixes discovered after PASS-2 was declared complete. R5 honesty gate triggered a third iterative deep sweep.

Three new anomaly classes found and fixed:

  1. Self-DOI errors in 5 of 8 deposition templates (CRITICAL) — B003-B007 .zenodo.*_v{8,9}.0.json claimed wrong canonical DOIs (one pointed at HTTP 404, another at a "Motor Vehicles" paper).
  2. Hallucinated / unrelated DOIs in related_identifiers19227779 and 19227841 do not exist on Zenodo; 19227835/839/843/845 resolve but to completely unrelated work (verified via Zenodo public API).
  3. D-series superseded DOIs — Zenodo's 2026-05-12 D-series republication retired 19020211/13/15/17 in favour of canonical 19020270/75/80/82; 35+ doc references updated.

See full NASA PASS-3 report: trios#264 — NASA PASS-3 RVR-003 comment

R5 verification (post-PASS-3): 0 hallucinated / 0 superseded / 0 self-DOI errors remain across all three repos.

Anchor: phi^2 + phi^-2 = 3 · R5-HONEST · 2026-05-12T16:30:00Z

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant