feat: multi-agent support — harness selection, instructions, skills & hooks (v0.16.0)

.context/decisions/016-multi-agent-harness.md

@@ -0,0 +1,111 @@
+# ADR-016: Multi-Agent Harness via Adapter Registry
+
+**Status:** Accepted
+**Date:** 2026-06-02
+**Version:** 1.0
+**Deciders:** Nicholas (Gocase)
+
+## Context
+
+dotcontext was built Claude-Code-first (ADR-004): a project-root `CLAUDE.md` plus `.claude/`
+commands, agents, and skills. ADR-004 explicitly accepted "tightly coupled to Claude Code
+(won't work with other AI tools)" as a tradeoff.
+
+The toolkit's value — the curated project instructions, decisions, and skills — is agent-agnostic.
+Coding agents have converged on a near-common convention: the **AGENTS.md** open standard
+(Linux-Foundation-stewarded, plain Markdown, nearest-file-wins). GitHub's spec-kit ships per-agent
+integrations; we want the same reach without abandoning the Claude-first ergonomics.
+
+Research (2026) on where each agent reads its project instruction/memory file:
+
+| Agent | Instructions file | Reads `AGENTS.md` natively? |
+|-------|-------------------|-----------------------------|
+| Claude Code | `CLAUDE.md` | No (but supports `@import`) |
+| OpenAI Codex | `AGENTS.md` | Yes (originator) |
+| opencode | `AGENTS.md` (also reads `CLAUDE.md`) | Yes |
+| GitHub Copilot | `AGENTS.md` / `.github/copilot-instructions.md` | Yes (since Aug 2025) |
+| Cursor (IDE + `cursor-agent` CLI) | `AGENTS.md` / `.cursor/rules/*.mdc` | Yes |
+| Gemini CLI | `GEMINI.md` | No (but supports `@import`; configurable) |
+
+## Decision
+
+### 1. Extensible adapter registry
+
+A registry (`src/setup/agents.sh`) declares each supported agent as a small record: `id`,
+display name, detection command (`command -v`), instructions filename, and emit mode. Adding an
+agent is one entry — nothing else in the toolkit hard-codes an agent. Initial set:
+`claude, codex, opencode, gemini, copilot, cursor` (the Cursor entry covers both the IDE and the
+`cursor-agent` CLI).
+
+### 2. `AGENTS.md` is the single canonical source of project instructions
+
+The real instruction content lives in **`AGENTS.md` at the repo root**. This natively covers
+**codex, opencode, copilot, and cursor** with zero extra files. The two agents that don't read
+`AGENTS.md` get thin **import stubs** pointing at it (both support `@import`):
+
+- `CLAUDE.md` → `@AGENTS.md` (for Claude Code)
+- `GEMINI.md` → `@AGENTS.md` (for Gemini CLI)
+
+Single source, no duplication, no drift; each editor edits `AGENTS.md`.
+
+### 3. Interactive agent detection (no new CLI flags)
+
+`dotcontext init` detects which agent CLIs are installed and emits the matching instruction files;
+in interactive mode it confirms the selection. `--yes` sets up all detected agents (falling back
+to Claude when none are detected). This honors the minimal-CLI constraint (ADR-007) — no
+`--agent` flag, the flow lives inside `init`.
+
+### 4. Safe migration for existing projects
+
+`dotcontext update` migrates legacy single-file projects: when a content-bearing `CLAUDE.md`
+exists and `AGENTS.md` does not, it offers to make `AGENTS.md` canonical (move the content) and
+leave `CLAUDE.md` as an `@AGENTS.md` stub. This is content-preserving and behavior-preserving for
+Claude (it still reads the same content via the import).
+
+### 5. Scope of this decision (phase 2a)
+
+This ADR covers the **instructions file** only. Skills and hooks portability is addressed in
+**ADR-017**; porting slash commands to each agent's native format is deferred to a later phase.
+
+> **Correction (2026-06-03):** an earlier draft of this ADR claimed "Codex/Gemini/etc. have no
+> structured-question API," used to justify a degraded `{{ASK}}` fallback. That premise is **false**.
+> Current research (see ADR-017) confirms **all six agents ship a model-callable structured-question
+> tool** (Claude `AskUserQuestion`, Codex `request_user_input`, opencode `question`, Gemini
+> `ask_user`, Copilot `ask_user`, Cursor `cursor/ask_question`) **and** lifecycle hooks. So command
+> portability (ADR-018) renders `{{ASK}}` to each agent's **native** question tool — it
+> does not degrade to free text. The `--version --json` handshake (ADR-015) flips `multiagent: true`
+> and lists supported `agents` as adapters land.
+
+## Consequences
+
+### Positive
+- The toolkit works across Claude, Codex, opencode, Copilot, Cursor, and Gemini from one source.
+- Adding a new agent is a single registry entry.
+- Existing Claude-only projects keep working and migrate safely.
+
+### Negative
+- A root `AGENTS.md` plus possible `CLAUDE.md`/`GEMINI.md` stubs is slightly more surface than a
+  lone `CLAUDE.md`.
+- Import resolution depends on each agent honoring `@import`; agents that don't are covered by
+  reading `AGENTS.md` directly, but a future agent that does neither would need a real copy.
+- Command/skill portability is **not** solved here (phase 2b).
+
+## Alternatives Considered
+
+1. **Keep `CLAUDE.md` canonical, point `AGENTS.md` at it via `@import`** — rejected: Codex/Copilot/
+   Cursor don't resolve `@import`, so they'd see a literal pointer instead of content.
+2. **Symlinks (`AGENTS.md` → `CLAUDE.md`)** — rejected: fragile on Windows/WSL (ADR cross-platform rule) and in git.
+3. **Full content copies per agent** — rejected: guarantees drift across files.
+4. **Per-agent zip artifacts (old spec-kit model)** — rejected: doesn't fit the single-bash-executable + curl distribution (ADR-001/002).
+
+## History
+
+| Version | Date | Changes |
+|---------|------|---------|
+| 1.0 | 2026-06-02 | Initial decision (phase 2a: instructions file across agents) |
+
+## Related
+- ADR-004: Claude Code integration (this extends it beyond Claude)
+- ADR-005: Mandatory AskUserQuestion (will get a v2.0 for command portability in phase 2b)
+- ADR-007: CLI simplification (interactive detection, no new flags)
+- ADR-015: Capability discovery & update awareness (the handshake this populates)

.context/decisions/017-skills-and-hooks-portability.md

@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
+# ADR-017: Harness Selection, Skills & Hooks Portability
+
+**Status:** Accepted
+**Date:** 2026-06-03
+**Version:** 1.0
+**Deciders:** Nicholas (Gocase)
+
+## Context
+
+ADR-016 made the project-instructions file (`AGENTS.md`) multi-agent. Two follow-ups remained:
+**skills** and **hooks**. Research (June 2026) overturned an earlier assumption: **all six target
+agents now implement the open Agent Skills (`SKILL.md`) standard, ship lifecycle hooks, and expose a
+model-callable structured-question tool** (so the `AskUserQuestion` premise in ADR-016's first draft
+was wrong — corrected there).
+
+Skills directory coverage:
+
+| Reads `.agents/skills/` | Reads `.claude/skills/` |
+|-------------------------|--------------------------|
+| Codex, opencode, Gemini, Copilot, Cursor | Claude, opencode, Copilot, Cursor |
+
+No single directory covers all six: **Claude only reads `.claude/skills/`**, and **Codex/Gemini do
+not read `.claude/skills/`**.
+
+A separate problem surfaced: the old `init` emitted **all** of `.claude/` (commands, agents,
+statusline, settings) plus `CLAUDE.md` unconditionally — junk for a user who only runs Codex or
+Gemini.
+
+## Decision
+
+### 1. Harness selection — only emit what the chosen agents use
+
+`dotcontext init` resolves a set of harnesses and emits files **only** for them:
+- **Interactive** (default): confirm each detected agent (default = detected set).
+- **`--agents claude,codex`** flag: non-interactive/scripted selection (a deliberate, scoped
+  exception to the minimal-CLI rule of ADR-007, for spec-kit `--integration` parity).
+- **`--yes`**: all detected agents (fallback to `claude` if none).
+
+Emission gating:
+- `AGENTS.md` (canonical instructions) + `.context/` skeleton + MCP → **always** (harness-agnostic).
+- `CLAUDE.md` stub + **all of `.claude/`** (commands, agents, statusline, `.claudeignore`) → **only if
+  Claude is selected**.
+- `GEMINI.md` stub → only if Gemini selected.
+- A Codex-only project therefore gets just `AGENTS.md` + `.agents/skills/` + a Codex hook — no `.claude/`.
+
+### 2. Skills — `.agents/skills/` canonical, mirrored to `.claude/skills/`
+
+The shared `SKILL.md` files are emitted to the physical directory matching the selection:
+- Claude selected → physical `.claude/skills/`; if an `AGENTS.md`-reading agent is also selected,
+  `.agents/skills/` is a symlink to it (copy fallback for filesystems without symlinks).
+- Claude not selected → physical `.agents/skills/`.
+
+dotcontext owns these files, so a single physical copy + symlink avoids drift (no `@import` exists for
+skills, unlike instructions).
+
+### 3. Hooks — a notification hook per selected harness
+
+Each selected harness gets a "task finished / needs attention" notification wired in its native config:
+- Claude → `.claude/settings.json` (existing: notify + tool-failure-guard).
+- Codex → `.codex/hooks.json`; Gemini → `.gemini/settings.json`; Copilot → `.github/hooks/dotcontext-notify.json`;
+  Cursor → `.cursor/hooks.json`; opencode → `.opencode/plugins/dotcontext-notify.js` (opencode has no
+  declarative hooks — only JS/TS plugins).
+- All point at a shared, **arg-driven** `notify.sh` (it takes title/message/sound as args and ignores
+  stdin, so the same script works regardless of each agent's hook JSON contract). Create-only — never
+  clobbers an existing agent config.
+
+**Scope limits (intentional):** only the **notification** hook ports. The richer
+`tool-failure-guard` stays **Claude-only** (it depends on Claude's `PostToolUseFailure` semantics, which
+don't map uniformly). Non-Claude hook configs are validated as well-formed (JSON/TOML/JS) but are
+**best-effort** — they are not end-to-end tested against each agent runtime.
+
+## Consequences
+
+### Positive
+- No junk: a project only carries files for the harnesses it actually uses.
+- Skills and notification hooks work across all six agents from shared sources.
+- Confirms command portability (ADR-018) is viable — every agent has a native
+  structured-question tool.
+
+### Negative
+- Per-agent hook configs are best-effort (not runtime-tested per agent); event-name/semantics differ
+  (e.g. Gemini uses `AfterAgent`, not `Stop`).
+- `tool-failure-guard` remains Claude-only.
+- A `--agents` flag widens the CLI surface (scoped exception, justified above).
+
+## Alternatives Considered
+
+1. **Emit everything for all agents always** — rejected: dumps junk (the problem this fixes).
+2. **One skills dir for all** — impossible: Claude and Codex/Gemini read disjoint directories.
+3. **Duplicate skill copies per ecosystem** — rejected: drift; symlink keeps one source.
+4. **Port `tool-failure-guard` everywhere** — rejected for now: no uniform failure-event semantics.
+
+## History
+
+| Version | Date | Changes |
+|---------|------|---------|
+| 1.0 | 2026-06-03 | Initial decision (harness selection, skills, notification hooks) |
+
+## Related
+- ADR-016: Multi-agent harness (instructions file) — this builds on it
+- ADR-005: Mandatory AskUserQuestion — ADR-018 renders `{{ASK}}` to each agent's native question tool to satisfy it cross-agent
+- ADR-007: CLI simplification — `--agents` is a scoped exception

.context/decisions/018-command-portability-and-invocation-modes.md

@@ -0,0 +1,79 @@
+# ADR-018: Command Portability & Invocation Modes (phase 2b plan)
+
+**Status:** Proposed
+**Date:** 2026-06-03
+**Deciders:** Nicholas (Gocase)
+
+## Context
+
+ADR-016/017 made instructions, skills, and hooks multi-agent. The remaining piece (phase 2b) is
+porting the 12 slash commands. Two facts shape the design:
+
+1. **Commands and skills have converged** (Claude Code): a `/x` command is effectively a skill with
+   `disable-model-invocation: true`. Skills (`SKILL.md`) port cleanly to all six agents (ADR-017);
+   classic per-repo commands do not (Codex prompts are global, Cursor has no file-based slash command).
+2. **Every agent ships a structured-question tool** (ADR-016 correction): Claude `AskUserQuestion`,
+   Codex `request_user_input`, opencode `question`, Gemini `ask_user`, Copilot `ask_user`, Cursor
+   `cursor/ask_question`. So requirement-gathering (ADR-005) is satisfiable on every agent.
+
+The tempting shortcut — "make everything a skill" — is **unsafe**: skills are model-auto-invocable,
+and `disable-model-invocation` (explicit-only) is honored only by Claude and Cursor. Auto-firing a
+side-effecting command (`/commit`, `/create-pr`) on the other agents would be a foot-gun.
+
+## Decision
+
+### 1. Each artifact declares an invocation mode
+
+- **`skill`** — auto-discoverable (model invokes by `description`) **and** explicitly invocable. For
+  read-mostly knowledge/analysis with no dangerous side effects.
+- **`command`** — explicit-only. For deliberate, side-effecting, or outward-facing actions.
+
+Classification (skills for knowledge, commands for action):
+
+| Mode `skill` | Mode `command` (explicit-only) |
+|---|---|
+| `bug-reproduction`, `batch-operations`, `git-platform` (existing guides) | `setup-context`, `generate-prp`, `execute-prp`, `commit`, `create-pr`, `pr-comment`, `add-decision`, `add-skill`, `add-command` |
+| **`code-review`**, **`deep-context`** (read-mostly analysis — promoted from command) | `fix-bug` (makes changes; leans on the `bug-reproduction` skill) |
+
+Rationale for the promotions: `code-review` and `deep-context` are read-mostly, and "review my changes"
+/ "help me understand X" are natural auto-triggers — discovery adds value with no side-effect risk, and
+the explicit `/name` still works.
+
+### 2. Emit per agent by mode
+
+- `skill` mode → `SKILL.md` (already ports to all six — ADR-017).
+- `command` mode → each agent's **explicit** primitive: Claude command, opencode command, Copilot
+  prompt file, Gemini custom command (TOML), Cursor skill + `disable-model-invocation`, Codex prompt
+  (global `~/.codex/prompts/`, namespaced). Where an agent only offers auto-skills, use its explicit
+  flag if honored, otherwise fall back to documenting the workflow in `AGENTS.md`.
+
+### 3. Portable `{{ASK}}` directive
+
+Command/skill bodies express requirement-gathering with a portable `{{ASK: question | optA | optB }}`
+directive. At emit time it renders to each agent's **native** structured-question tool — it does **not**
+degrade to free text. This satisfies ADR-005's clarity-assessed questioning on every agent.
+
+## Consequences
+
+- **Positive:** preserves the safe boundary (knowledge = skill, action = command); no side-effecting
+  auto-invocation; `{{ASK}}` keeps the ADR-005 contract everywhere.
+- **Negative:** the emitter must implement per-agent command formats + the `{{ASK}}` renderer; Codex
+  commands remain global; Cursor commands ride on the skill+flag path.
+
+## Alternatives Considered
+
+1. **All artifacts as auto-skills** — rejected: unsafe (auto-firing side effects; `disable-model-invocation`
+   not universal).
+2. **All as classic commands** — rejected: don't port (Codex global, Cursor none).
+3. **Free-text fallback for `{{ASK}}`** — rejected: unnecessary, every agent has a native question tool.
+
+## History
+
+| Version | Date | Changes |
+|---------|------|---------|
+| 1.0 (proposed) | 2026-06-03 | Initial plan for phase 2b |
+
+## Related
+- ADR-005: Mandatory AskUserQuestion (clarity assessment) — `{{ASK}}` is how it's satisfied cross-agent
+- ADR-016: Multi-agent harness (instructions)
+- ADR-017: Harness selection, skills & hooks portability

CHANGELOG.md

@@ -1,5 +1,22 @@
 # Changelog
 
+## [0.16.0](https://github.com/goca-se/dotcontext/compare/v0.15.0...v0.16.0) (2026-06-03)
+
+### Features
+
+* **multi-agent support** — dotcontext now targets six harnesses (Claude Code, OpenAI Codex, opencode, Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot, Cursor incl. `cursor-agent`) instead of Claude only (ADR-016, ADR-017):
+  * **extensible adapter registry** (`src/setup/agents.sh`) — each agent is one entry (`id`, name, detection, instructions file, emit mode). Adding an agent is a single case arm
+  * **harness selection — only emit what you choose** — `init` confirms each detected agent interactively, or takes `--agents claude,codex` (non-interactive), or `--yes` (all detected). A Codex-only project gets **no `.claude/`** — no junk
+  * **instructions** — canonical **`AGENTS.md`** read natively by Codex/opencode/Copilot/Cursor; **Claude** (`CLAUDE.md`) and **Gemini** (`GEMINI.md`) via thin `@AGENTS.md` import stubs. Single source, no duplication
+  * **skills** — shared `SKILL.md` content emitted to `.agents/skills/` (Codex/opencode/Gemini/Copilot/Cursor) mirrored to `.claude/skills/` (Claude) via symlink (copy fallback)
+  * **hooks** — a "task finished / needs attention" notification wired per selected harness in its native config (`.codex/hooks.json`, `.gemini/settings.json`, `.github/hooks/`, `.cursor/hooks.json`, opencode JS plugin); Claude also keeps the tool-failure guard
+  * **`update` migrates legacy projects** — a content-bearing `CLAUDE.md` with no `AGENTS.md` is offered migration into the shared `AGENTS.md` (content- and behavior-preserving), plus a `GEMINI.md` stub when the Gemini CLI is present
+  * **`--version --json`** reports `multiagent: true`, `skills: true`, `hooks: true` and the supported `agents` list; **`doctor`** is `AGENTS.md`-aware and reports detected agents
+
+### Notes
+
+* Slash **commands** remain Claude-native; per-agent command ports (ADR-018 — invocation-mode classification + a portable `{{ASK}}` rendered to each agent's native structured-question tool) are the next phase. Non-Claude hook configs are validated as well-formed but are best-effort (not runtime-tested per agent); the tool-failure guard stays Claude-only.
+
 ## [0.15.0](https://github.com/goca-se/dotcontext/compare/v0.14.2...v0.15.0) (2026-06-02)
 
 ### Features

Makefile

@@ -10,6 +10,7 @@ SOURCES = \
 	src/core/utils.sh \
 	src/setup/notifications.sh \
 	src/setup/mcp.sh \
+	src/setup/agents.sh \
 	src/commands/init.sh \
 	src/commands/update.sh \
 	src/commands/doctor.sh \