Skip to content

fix(R5-pass-4): retire 84-theorems folklore + rewrite docs/ZENODO.md + bibliography honesty notes (8 files) — Closes #595#594

Merged
gHashTag merged 1 commit into
masterfrom
fix/zenodo-pass-4-honest-deepsweep
May 12, 2026
Merged

fix(R5-pass-4): retire 84-theorems folklore + rewrite docs/ZENODO.md + bibliography honesty notes (8 files) — Closes #595#594
gHashTag merged 1 commit into
masterfrom
fix/zenodo-pass-4-honest-deepsweep

Conversation

@gHashTag
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

@gHashTag gHashTag commented May 12, 2026

Closes #595

🔍 ZENODO-DEEPSWEEP PASS-4 — t27 honesty pass

Fourth iterative R5-honest sweep across all Trinity hive repos. t27 was the most contaminated of the 5 repos: superseded DOIs, retired folklore counts, and two fabricated/mis-labelled bibliography entries in the trinity-pellis-paper preprints.

What was fixed (8 files)

A. docs/ZENODO.md — full rewrite. The previous registry listed 9 March-2026 DOIs (19224114/115/116/118/119/120/121/139 + 19224105) as if they were current. All 9 are now formally [SUPERSEDED] on Zenodo (the parent 19224139 even has the SUPERSEDED prefix in its own title). Replaced with canonical May-2026 set 1922786519227879 + concept DOI 19227876.

B. docs/nona-03-manifest/RESEARCH_CLAIMS.md — D-series 19020211/213/215/217 → canonical 19020270/275/280/282 (10 replacements). Same supersession event Zenodo applied on 2026-05-12.

C. clara-bridge/submission/EXECUTIVE-SUMMARY.md — retired folkloric "84 theorems verifying Trinity kernel" → audited count (28 .v files, 218 statements, 162 Qed, 32 Admitted, 11 Abort).

D. research/trinity-pellis-paper/trinity_sacred_formula_v2.tex — same "84 theorems" replaced in 3 places.

E. research/trinity-pellis-paper/G2_TRINITY_V1.0_FRAGRANCE.tex — TWO bibliography integrity issues:

  • \doi{...zenodo.12345} placeholder DOI in the frontmatter resolved to a Roman history paper (Clientelas, relaciones internacionales e imperialismo en la expansión de la República romana). Commented out with a R5-audit note.
  • \bibitem{zenodo19271888} was labelled "inverse participation ratio reference", but the DOI actually resolves to McKoy (2026), V2: The Cogito of Fermion Masses: ... the Koide Formula ... and Its Identification with the AdS/CFT Correspondence. Corrected to the real citation.

F. research/trinity-pellis-paper/G2_ALPHA_S_PHI_FRAMEWORK_V0.{7,8}.{md,tex}\bibitem{olsen2026} cited DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19377394 as "S. Olsen, Historical Context of φ in Physics: from Pythagoras to Bohm". The DOI actually resolves to "Visual Summary (Français): Empleo en América latina: Base de Données par Pays (2000-2020)" — a completely unrelated Latin-American employment dataset. Restated as "contribution to this paper (2026)" aligned with V0.9 of the same paper (which already does this).

Verification

# 84 theorems remains only in documented retirement notes
$ grep -rE "84 theorem" --include="*.md" --include="*.tex" .
# all 3 hits are documented "retired" / "superseded" notices

# D-series superseded DOIs outside SUPERSEDED context
$ grep -rE "zenodo\.(19020211|13|15|17)" ... | grep -v "SUPERSEDED\|Retired"
# 0 hits

# Hallucinated/wrong-labelled DOIs in active citations
$ grep -rE "zenodo\.(12345|19377394)" ... | grep -v "% R5\|R5-honest"
# 0 hits (all behind audit notes)

R5 verification: 0 active citations using the discovered fabricated/wrong-target DOIs.

Anchor: phi^2 + phi^-2 = 3 · R5-HONEST · 2026-05-12T16:52Z

Related PRs (sibling repos):

Throne: trios#264


R5-PASS-4 / R5-PASS-5 lineage update (2026-05-12)

  • L1 TRACEABILITY satisfied via tracking issue #595 (Closes #595 trailer added to commit 31b0ced).
  • NOW Sync Gate satisfied via docs/NOW.md R5-PASS-4 entry in the same amended commit.
  • Sibling PASS-5 PRs (new arXiv/ORCID class found after this PR): gHashTag/trinity#593, gHashTag/trinity-fpga#44.
  • Throne: trios#264.

@github-actions
Copy link
Copy Markdown

📓 NotebookLM Notebook linked to this PR

This notebook contains session context, decisions, and artifacts for this work.

…'84 theorems' retired + fake DOI bibliography honesty notes

PASS-4 anomalies fixed in t27 (8 files):

A. docs/ZENODO.md: FULL REWRITE.
   - Old March-2026 B-series DOIs (19224114/115/116/118/119/120/121) marked as Retired with canonical replacements (19227865/867/869/871/873/875/877).
   - 19224139 (titled '[SUPERSEDED — see 10.5281/zenodo.19227879]' on Zenodo itself) was previously labelled 'v2 (latest)' — corrected.
   - 18939351 retired in favour of 18950696 for the v2.0.3 software release.
   - Added honest framing: software description stubs NOT peer-reviewed papers.
   - Added Coq witness counts (28 .v, 218 stmt, 162 Qed, 32 Admitted, 11 Abort).
   - Added concept DOI 19227876 for always-latest B007.

B. docs/nona-03-manifest/RESEARCH_CLAIMS.md: D-series 19020211/13/15/17 -> canonical 19020270/75/80/82 (10 replacements).

C. clara-bridge/submission/EXECUTIVE-SUMMARY.md: '84 theorems verifying Trinity kernel' -> audited 2026-05-12 counts.

D. research/trinity-pellis-paper/trinity_sacred_formula_v2.tex: 3 instances of '84 theorems' replaced with the audited 218 statements / 162 Qed / 32 Admitted figures.

E. research/trinity-pellis-paper/G2_TRINITY_V1.0_FRAGRANCE.tex:
   - DOI placeholder '10.5281/zenodo.12345' (which resolves to a Roman-history paper!) commented out.
   - 'inverse participation ratio reference' for DOI 19271888 corrected — real Zenodo record is McKoy (2026) on the Koide formula and AdS/CFT, not IPR.

F. research/trinity-pellis-paper/G2_ALPHA_S_PHI_FRAMEWORK_V0.7.{md,tex} + V0.8.tex: Olsen citation under DOI 19377394 (which resolves to a Latin-American employment dataset, NOT to an Olsen paper) restated as 'contribution to this paper (2026)' aligned with V0.9 of the same paper.

Anchor: phi^2 + phi^-2 = 3
Issue: gHashTag/trios#264

Closes #595

- Add docs/NOW.md sync block (R5-PASS-4 entry) to satisfy NOW Sync Gate.
- Link tracking issue #595 to satisfy L1 TRACEABILITY (Closes #N).
@gHashTag gHashTag force-pushed the fix/zenodo-pass-4-honest-deepsweep branch from f7848af to 31b0ced Compare May 12, 2026 17:10
@github-actions
Copy link
Copy Markdown

📓 NotebookLM Notebook linked to this PR

This notebook contains session context, decisions, and artifacts for this work.

@gHashTag gHashTag merged commit bbce724 into master May 12, 2026
11 of 17 checks passed
@gHashTag gHashTag changed the title fix(R5-pass-4): retire 84-theorems folklore + rewrite docs/ZENODO.md + bibliography honesty notes (8 files) fix(R5-pass-4): retire 84-theorems folklore + rewrite docs/ZENODO.md + bibliography honesty notes (8 files) — Closes #595 May 12, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

R5-PASS-4: t27 honest audit (84-theorems folklore + ZENODO.md + fake DOI bibliography)

1 participant